Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-28 Thread Marco Gerards
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > Could someone who knows the code please envisage what should be done > in order to implement the mkfs module? First of all, I would not call the command mkfs. Better just restrict the functionality to swap, that can give you some assertions to begin with. First just

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-13 Thread technologypages
Tomáš, unfortunately your solution to the swap sharing problem is suboptimal -- swapping through filesystem code to a file in a VFAT filesystem will quite likely be a order of magnitude slower than raw partition access. It's OK if you are a casual Linux user, but not acceptable if you are a cas

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-12 Thread Yoshinori K. Okuji
On Saturday 11 March 2006 20:46, Marco Gerards wrote: > Heh, now I am defending a feature I don't really want, need or care > about myself. It's just that the idea is not that bad, not that I > want it or so. Interesting. :) BTW, if one really wants to implement fancy partition manipulation feat

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-11 Thread Tomáš Ebenlendr
On 11 Březen 2006, 21:46, Marco Gerards napsal(a): > "Yoshinori K. Okuji" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > >>> The main reason for this feature request was that swap space can be >>> shared between windows and GNU/Linux this way. So you can make a fat >>> filesystem when booting windows and a swap f

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-11 Thread Marco Gerards
"Yoshinori K. Okuji" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >> The main reason for this feature request was that swap space can be >> shared between windows and GNU/Linux this way. So you can make a fat >> filesystem when booting windows and a swap filesystem when booting >> GNU/Linux. Although this is not

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-11 Thread Vesa Jääskeläinen
Marco Gerards wrote: > [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > >> Can someone please comment if adding filesystem creation support to >> grub is reasonable. >> >> Please see the rationale at >> http://www.geocities.com/technologypages/grub-mkfs.txt >> >> Will the developers consider adding this feature? It is

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-11 Thread Yoshinori K. Okuji
On Saturday 11 March 2006 14:37, Marco Gerards wrote: > Unfortunately the rationale behind this idea was not in the original > email. I know. > The main reason for this feature request was that swap space can be > shared between windows and GNU/Linux this way. So you can make a fat > filesystem

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-11 Thread Marco Gerards
"Yoshinori K. Okuji" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > On Friday 10 March 2006 21:44, Marco Gerards wrote: >> I think it is easy to implement this feature, and agree it might be >> useful in the cases you described. I wonder how the other developers >> think about including such feature. > > For me,

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-11 Thread Yoshinori K. Okuji
On Friday 10 March 2006 21:44, Marco Gerards wrote: > I think it is easy to implement this feature, and agree it might be > useful in the cases you described. I wonder how the other developers > think about including such feature. For me, this kind of feature is an OS's task rather than a boot lo

Re: mkfs command in grub

2006-03-10 Thread Marco Gerards
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > Can someone please comment if adding filesystem creation support to > grub is reasonable. > > Please see the rationale at > http://www.geocities.com/technologypages/grub-mkfs.txt > > Will the developers consider adding this feature? It is rather easy to > implement as f

mkfs command in grub

2006-03-10 Thread technologypages
Can someone please comment if adding filesystem creation support to grub is reasonable. Please see the rationale at http://www.geocities.com/technologypages/grub-mkfs.txt Will the developers consider adding this feature? It is rather easy to implement as far as I can see -- only glue for ext