Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2016-01-08 Thread Gervase Markham
On 05/01/16 22:20, Benjamin Kerensa wrote: > I think having a emeritus role doesn't make sense and think it will be one > more thing that someone has to keep updated. There is no requirement to keep it updated; I would expect being listed to be driven by the ex-owner themselves, who wanted to be a

Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2016-01-08 Thread Gervase Markham
Hi Majken, On 05/01/16 21:39, Majken Connor wrote: > I'm not so sure. This is really a question of what's the purpose of this > module, and of the module system at all! The purpose of the module system is to be the core of the governance of the Mozilla project. (Whether it adequately fulfils that

Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2016-01-05 Thread Johnny Stenback
I think it's reasonable to leave enough flexibility in this system for current owners, or even previous owners, to reflect defacto owners in cases like the one Andrew describes. Noone will argue that Graydon, who wrote the cycle collector, wasn't the module owner at the time. We just hadn't made th

Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2016-01-05 Thread Benjamin Kerensa
I think we know that recognition is lacking this was something CBT at one point was trying to fix but since CBT was disbanded it seems recognition was dropped also as something to solve. I think having a emeritus role doesn't make sense and think it will be one more thing that someone has to keep

Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2016-01-05 Thread Majken Connor
I'm not so sure. This is really a question of what's the purpose of this module, and of the module system at all! My first question would be why use this as a mode of recognition for people who weren't in modules? Do other recognition tools not exist? Are they lacking? Which method should be impro

Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2016-01-05 Thread Gervase Markham
On 31/12/15 18:51, Andrew McCreight wrote: > I suppose technically a module owner can name anybody an emeritus peer by > synthesizing it out of existing module owner operations (name person as > peer, remove them as peer, add them as emeritus peer), so maybe that's > sufficient for giving people in

Re: Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2015-12-31 Thread Andrew McCreight
On Wed, Dec 23, 2015 at 4:27 AM, Gervase Markham wrote: > Hi everyone, > > We have now implemented the idea of Owners Emeritus and Peers Emeritus > for Mozilla modules. ("Emeritus" is a Latin word which is used in > English to indicate people who no longer do a job, but are marked as > having don

Module Owners and Peers Emeritus

2015-12-23 Thread Gervase Markham
Hi everyone, We have now implemented the idea of Owners Emeritus and Peers Emeritus for Mozilla modules. ("Emeritus" is a Latin word which is used in English to indicate people who no longer do a job, but are marked as having done the job in the past. It's an honourary position.) We have implemen