Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-02-01 Thread sherwood kaip
Here is what apparently happened that I could no longer save changed or added gnucash data. I don't remember specifying where to store data when I first installed gnucash years ago. Apparently it stored the files in a hidden folder called opt or /opt. I never saw this folder until someone told

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-27 Thread Malcolm Fitzgerald
I'm with D on this one. /opt isn't the best spot for user documents. It's completely hidden from the Finder and will require you to jump hurdles at every step. It really doesn't want you doing things there. Turning SIPS off is generally bad. Turning SIPS off temporarily may be necessary. Some o

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-26 Thread GWB
If anyone wants to experiment with this, it is possible to selectively enable and disable specifics parts of SIP: https://eclecticlight.co/2016/05/03/sip-and-rootless-protecting-more-than-just-system-files/ https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/17452 To enable SIP but without filesystem prot

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-26 Thread GWB
Apple OS X combined two types of kernels, bsd and mach, but is (according to some FreeBSD kernel developers) progressively removing the mach kernel components. This may be due to their possible shift to ARM processors for computers (same family of processors as their other devices). But Apple doe

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-26 Thread John Ralls
Not only that, while Darwin (the underlying unix core of all Apple operating systems) is BSD Unix, it is *not* Linux and doesn't subscribe to the Linux Foundation or Free Desktop standards. Not that that matters. I just created /opt on my Mac running Catalina, changed the privs to 777, and save

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-26 Thread Adrien Monteleone
Why are you storing your book in /opt? That should more likely be in your /Users directory along with the rest of your own files. (or on some other volume) Catalina separated your internal system drive into 2 partitions. Check Disk Manager. It will now show (default names) ‘Macintosh HD’ and ‘M

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-26 Thread D via gnucash-user
And yet, still unanswered is why a user would put their data files into /opt in the first place... On Jan 26, 2020, 15:49, at 15:49, Christian Lynbech wrote: >I am fuzzy on the details, but one of the changes in catalina (as a way >to implement SIP) is that the main is mounted twice, one mount p

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-26 Thread Christian Lynbech
I am fuzzy on the details, but one of the changes in catalina (as a way to implement SIP) is that the main is mounted twice, one mount point is read only and if one is accessimg /opt via the wrong mountpoint, wrting is prohibited. I also use MacPorts under catalina without problems, but that doe

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-25 Thread D via gnucash-user
Whether the application files are placed in /opt by MacPorts, or /Applications by the user has no bearing on the location of the data files. Those are usually placed in the user's folders. On January 26, 2020, at 11:44 AM, Peter West wrote: This doesn’t sound right. I use MacPorts, and MacPo

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-25 Thread Peter West
This doesn’t sound right. I use MacPorts, and MacPorts puts all if its files under /opt. I haven’t seen ant references on the MacPorts mailing list to /opt being reserved under SIP. Peter -- Peter West p...@pbw.id.au …he rebuked them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they had not

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-25 Thread D via gnucash-user
It might be worth asking why OP is using /opt for their data files in the first place. It is more usual for users to place their personal files in the /users hierarchy (i.e., ~/). On January 26, 2020, at 8:33 AM, Bruce Schuck wrote: It seems that maybe the /opt directory tree is being restric

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-25 Thread Bruce Schuck
It seems that maybe the /opt directory tree is being restricted by what OSX called System Integrity Protection. Try following the steps to turn off SIP here: http://osxdaily.com/2015/10/05/disable-rootless-system-integrity-protection-mac-os-x/ If not, please open a terminal window and supply t

Re: [GNC] since Catalina, unable to open gnucash

2020-01-25 Thread David H
Good news both of them came thru :-) Looks like Gnucash can't save files to the folder you previously saved to - Catalina enforces some sort of permissions on folders these days. Check System Preferences >> Security & Privacy - click on the Privacy tab and scroll down to "Files and Folders" and c