Re: [GNC-dev] GncCombott Widget

2021-02-18 Thread Robert Fewell
Thanks for the feedback, I have created PR 917 to replace the GncCombott with a GtkComboBox. Regards, Bob On Tue, 16 Feb 2021 at 17:13, Geert Janssens wrote: > Thanks. I'm fine with the dropping value listings in tooltips as well. The > only reason I considered them was for the cases where per-

Re: [GNC-dev] GncCombott Widget

2021-02-16 Thread Geert Janssens
Thanks. I'm fine with the dropping value listings in tooltips as well. The only reason I considered them was for the cases where per-value extra info would be needed. In my quick evaluation of a number of them that doesn't really seem necessary. Regards, Geert Op dinsdag 16 februari 2021 17

Re: [GNC-dev] GncCombott Widget

2021-02-16 Thread John Ralls
I generally agree, but I think that there's no great benefit to listing the available options in most cases. The user can easily enough click the revealer to see them. I also don't think that we want dissertation-length tooltips. If that much verbiage is required then it should be in the help do

Re: [GNC-dev] GncCombott Widget

2021-02-16 Thread Geert Janssens
Hi Bob, I did some experiments and I agree with you it would be hard to implement this in Gtk3 because the tooltips should be added to the internal GtkMenu. The GtkCombobox interface does not provide access to that widget. So there is a trade-off to make here between maintenance burden and adde

Re: [GNC-dev] GncCombott Widget

2021-02-16 Thread Christopher Lam
Hi Robert The reality is that you're probably the most skilled in gtk in here so your view is likely the best one. However I agree that replicating gtkcombobox is probably unnecessary. My personal view is that tooltips are an obscure mechanism to display additional (occasionally crucial) useful i

[GNC-dev] GncCombott Widget

2021-02-16 Thread Robert Fewell
Hi, In bug 798109 it was highlighted that the widget I wrote back in 2012 does not respond to keyboard use well which I think would be relatively easy to fix and maybe a couple of tweaks. Geert suggested that it could be dropped in favour of a traditional GtkComboBox. The reason I wrote it was t