RE: Re: Policy on Initial Committership

2006-10-07 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Cliff Schmidt wrote: > What I believe we've found works best over the years is to consider > the entire behavior of the project over its incubation and raise > questions about any trends pushing it in the wrong direction. I agree. It is about people making decisions, not rules making decisions f

Re: Re: Policy on Initial Committership

2006-10-07 Thread Justin Erenkrantz
--On October 6, 2006 5:38:37 AM -0700 Cliff Schmidt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I wish we could just have an objective list of numerical requirements, but I think it has to come down to the judgement of the Incubator PMC members. Umm, we do. At least 3 legally independent (and active) committ

Re: Re: Policy on Initial Committership

2006-10-06 Thread Cliff Schmidt
On 10/6/06, Niclas Hedhman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: If the Proposer controls the Proposal (and not stick it on a freely editable Wiki), then isn't it very straight forward? +1, although I think a Wiki still *should* work if the established etiquette was not to make edits to someone else's pro