Re: Add 'practice' PMC structure to projects in incubation

2003-11-23 Thread Nicola Ken Barozzi
Roy T. Fielding wrote: ... The ability to make ASF decisions starts with the board and is delegated to officers and their associated committees. Anyone casting binding votes (meaning votes that are counted toward making a decision) must be listed as a member of the committee on which they are voti

Re: Add 'practice' PMC structure to projects in incubation

2003-11-23 Thread Nicola Ken Barozzi
Sam Ruby wrote: Roy T. Fielding wrote: ... Jakarta got into a weird state wherein committer == voter and commit-access was given out like candy, thus leading to the notion that committers run ASF projects. I don't believe it is appropriate to link voting with cvs access. ... P.S. Can somebody exp

Re: Add 'practice' PMC structure to projects in incubation

2003-11-23 Thread Nicola Ken Barozzi
Phil Steitz wrote: ... Are you proposing that committers who are not PMC members or "Project Committers" should not have voting rights? On the PMC list it has come out that we were misunderstanding each other over the term "binding votes". Let me explain what we said. Some talked about a vote m

Re: Add 'practice' PMC structure to projects in incubation

2003-11-23 Thread Berin Lautenbach
Roy, Thankyou. Read with great interest, and it put a few things into perspective. Particularly the fact that to me the Practice PMCs made no sense from my perspective (based in the XML project's world). I think I now understand why. Couple of things came to mind whilst I was ruminating on

RE: Apache Gallery Project

2003-11-23 Thread Jay Zylstra
I didn't mean that the gallery would be under LGPL specifically, but something akin to it. As I understand, there are really three types of licensing for intellectual property: 1) Owner restricts access to the property, and charges to use it (Microsoft, SCO, etc.) 2) Owner allows others to u