Re: GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread Richard Kenner
But before we can roll out this compiler, we need to have some written statement from FSF that says it's legally safe to link with these libraries even with those problematic files. Who should I contact for such a statement? Your attorney. The FSF would have absolutely no reason t

Re: GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread Peter Naulls
Mike Stump wrote: On Jun 9, 2006, at 12:28 PM, xiaoyi wang wrote: In order to make sure that our proprietary code is not exposed to GPL restrictions by using gcc, Thanks for the audit. I'm getting the feeling that we should introduce features into the files and give hard compilation errors w

Re: GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread Mike Stump
On Jun 9, 2006, at 2:49 PM, xiaoyi wang wrote: Since we are on a very tight schedule to migrate to gcc4.1.0, we cannot wait until gcc4.2 to be released. But before we can roll out this compiler, we need to have some written statement from FSF that says it's legally safe to link with these librari

Re: GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread Joe Buck
On Fri, Jun 09, 2006 at 12:28:38PM -0700, xiaoyi wang wrote: > Here are the problematic files I found that only have > GPL without exception clauses in gcc4.1.0: For some of those files, it's intentional: libbfd is only for use by GPL software (as/ld) and is not for general use. They are not link

Re: GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread xiaoyi wang
Mike, Thank you for your reply. I will file a PR shortly. Since we are on a very tight schedule to migrate to gcc4.1.0, we cannot wait until gcc4.2 to be released. But before we can roll out this compiler, we need to have some written statement from FSF that says it's legally safe to link with t

Re: GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread Mike Stump
On Jun 9, 2006, at 12:28 PM, xiaoyi wang wrote: In order to make sure that our proprietary code is not exposed to GPL restrictions by using gcc, Thanks for the audit. I'm getting the feeling that we should introduce features into the files and give hard compilation errors when the rules a

GPL question: Use gcc to build proprietary software

2006-06-09 Thread xiaoyi wang
Hi, I got a question regarding GPL while migrating our code to gcc4.1.0. In order to make sure that our proprietary code is not exposed to GPL restrictions by using gcc, I run my scripts to check every source file and included header files that are built into gcc essential libraries such as libgc