Re: CGEN-generated files vs GPL

2009-01-28 Thread Joe Buck
On Wed, Jan 28, 2009 at 02:05:45PM -0800, Joseph S. Myers wrote: > On Wed, 28 Jan 2009, DJ Delorie wrote: > > > What are the implications (GPL-wise) of using CGEN-generated files in > > gcc? Specifically, I'm working on a second attempt to contribute the > > MeP port, and its intrinsics are CGEN-

Re: CGEN-generated files vs GPL

2009-01-28 Thread Joseph S. Myers
On Wed, 28 Jan 2009, DJ Delorie wrote: > > I believe the source code (i.e., what you'd change to modify the > > intrinsics) needs including in the GCC release tarballs. I don't > > think CGEN itself needs including, any more than OCaml needs > > including because the ARM NEON intrinsic generators

Re: CGEN-generated files vs GPL

2009-01-28 Thread DJ Delorie
> I believe the source code (i.e., what you'd change to modify the > intrinsics) needs including in the GCC release tarballs. I don't > think CGEN itself needs including, any more than OCaml needs > including because the ARM NEON intrinsic generators are written in > OCaml. The same cgen files p

Re: CGEN-generated files vs GPL

2009-01-28 Thread Joseph S. Myers
On Wed, 28 Jan 2009, DJ Delorie wrote: > What are the implications (GPL-wise) of using CGEN-generated files in > gcc? Specifically, I'm working on a second attempt to contribute the > MeP port, and its intrinsics are CGEN-generated (and there are a *lot* > of them - most opcodes have an intrinsic

Re: CGEN-generated files vs GPL

2009-01-28 Thread Frank Ch. Eigler
DJ Delorie writes: > What are the implications (GPL-wise) of using CGEN-generated files in > gcc? Specifically, I'm working on a second attempt to contribute the > MeP port, and its intrinsics are CGEN-generated (and there are a *lot* > of them - most opcodes have an intrinsic). [...] My under

CGEN-generated files vs GPL

2009-01-28 Thread DJ Delorie
What are the implications (GPL-wise) of using CGEN-generated files in gcc? Specifically, I'm working on a second attempt to contribute the MeP port, and its intrinsics are CGEN-generated (and there are a *lot* of them - most opcodes have an intrinsic). I'd rather not have to manually enter all t