Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-07 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Richard Sandiford writes: > Sam James writes: >> Richard Sandiford writes: >> >>> Sam James via Gcc writes: Hi! This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally writing an RFC. >>> [...] TL;DR: The proposal is: 1) MAINTAINERS should list a field c

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-07 Thread Richard Sandiford via Gcc
Sam James writes: > Richard Sandiford writes: > >> Sam James via Gcc writes: >>> Hi! >>> >>> This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally >>> writing an RFC. >>> >> [...] >>> TL;DR: The proposal is: >>> >>> 1) MAINTAINERS should list a field containing either the gcc.gnu.org >>> email

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-05 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Richard Sandiford writes: > Sam James via Gcc writes: >> Hi! >> >> This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally >> writing an RFC. >> > [...] >> TL;DR: The proposal is: >> >> 1) MAINTAINERS should list a field containing either the gcc.gnu.org >> email in full, or their gcc username (

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-04 Thread Richard Sandiford via Gcc
Sam James via Gcc writes: > Hi! > > This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally > writing an RFC. > > What? > --- > > I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, > adding an extra field for their GCC/sourceware account: >account> > Joe Bloggs

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-04 Thread Arsen Arsenović via Gcc
"Richard Earnshaw (lists)" writes: > On 25/06/2024 20:08, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: >> Hi, >> >> Richard Biener writes: >> >>> [snip] I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing that the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org email.

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-04 Thread Arsen Arsenović via Gcc
Hi, "Richard Earnshaw (lists)" writes: > On 24/06/2024 23:34, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: >> Hi, >> >> Sam James via Gcc writes: >> >>> Hi! >>> >>> This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally >>> writing an RFC. >>> >>> What? >>> --- >>> >>> I propose that MAINTAINERS be modifi

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-03 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Sam James via Gcc writes: > Gerald Pfeifer writes: > >> On Mon, 24 Jun 2024, Jonathan Wakely via Gcc wrote: 1) MAINTAINERS should list a field containing either the gcc.gnu.org email in full, or their gcc username (bikeshedding semi-welcome); >>> I like the proposal. I'd say it should

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-03 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Gerald Pfeifer writes: > On Wed, 3 Jul 2024, Sam James wrote: >>> Now, a bigger question: Why would anyone need to know my gcc.gnu.org >>> username (or e-mail address) in the Bugzilla context? >> Isn't it answered in the original proposal? It makes CCing the committer >> of a bisect result way

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-03 Thread Gerald Pfeifer
On Wed, 3 Jul 2024, Sam James wrote: >> Now, a bigger question: Why would anyone need to know my gcc.gnu.org >> username (or e-mail address) in the Bugzilla context? > Isn't it answered in the original proposal? It makes CCing the committer > of a bisect result way easier. No, it's not. And no,

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-03 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Gerald Pfeifer writes: > On Mon, 24 Jun 2024, Jonathan Wakely via Gcc wrote: >>> 1) MAINTAINERS should list a field containing either the gcc.gnu.org >>> email in full, or their gcc username (bikeshedding semi-welcome); >> I like the proposal. I'd say it should be fine to just put the gcc >> user

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-07-03 Thread Gerald Pfeifer
On Mon, 24 Jun 2024, Jonathan Wakely via Gcc wrote: >> 1) MAINTAINERS should list a field containing either the gcc.gnu.org >> email in full, or their gcc username (bikeshedding semi-welcome); > I like the proposal. I'd say it should be fine to just put the gcc > username (without the @gcc.gnu.org

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Richard Earnshaw (lists) via Gcc
On 25/06/2024 20:08, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: > Hi, > > Richard Biener writes: > >> [snip] >>> I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing >>> that the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org >>> email. This can be configured repo-locally via: >>>

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Richard Earnshaw (lists) via Gcc
On 27/06/2024 13:29, Sam James via Gcc wrote: > "Richard Earnshaw (lists)" writes: > >> On 24/06/2024 22:34, Sam James via Gcc wrote: >>> Hi! >>> >>> This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally >>> writing an RFC. >>> >>> What? >>> --- >>> >>> I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Richard Earnshaw (lists) via Gcc
On 24/06/2024 23:34, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: > Hi, > > Sam James via Gcc writes: > >> Hi! >> >> This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally >> writing an RFC. >> >> What? >> --- >> >> I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, >> adding an extra field for their

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Jonathan Wakely via Gcc
On Thu, 27 Jun 2024 at 13:26, Richard Earnshaw (lists) via Gcc wrote: > > On 24/06/2024 22:34, Sam James via Gcc wrote: > > Hi! > > > > This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally > > writing an RFC. > > > > What? > > --- > > > > I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Sam James via Gcc
"Richard Earnshaw (lists)" writes: > On 24/06/2024 22:34, Sam James via Gcc wrote: >> Hi! >> >> This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally >> writing an RFC. >> >> What? >> --- >> >> I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, >> adding an extra field for their GCC/s

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Richard Earnshaw (lists) via Gcc
On 24/06/2024 22:34, Sam James via Gcc wrote: > Hi! > > This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally > writing an RFC. > > What? > --- > > I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, > adding an extra field for their GCC/sourceware account: >a

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-27 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Arsen Arsenović writes: > Hi, > > Richard Biener writes: > >> [snip] >>> I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing >>> that the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org >>> email. This can be configured repo-locally via: >>> >>> $ git config committer

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Arsen Arsenović via Gcc
Hi, Thomas Koenig via Gcc writes: > Am 25.06.24 um 21:08 schrieb Arsen Arsenović via Gcc: > >> Richard Biener writes: > >>> I'd welcome this - care to create a patch for >>> contrib/gcc-git-customization.sh? >> Sure - I've attached a partial patch. I didn't find the hook which runs >> on each

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Thomas Koenig via Gcc
Am 25.06.24 um 21:08 schrieb Arsen Arsenović via Gcc: Richard Biener writes: I'd welcome this - care to create a patch for contrib/gcc-git-customization.sh? Sure - I've attached a partial patch. I didn't find the hook which runs on each push to check commits, so the current patch is minim

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Arsen Arsenović via Gcc
Hi, Richard Biener writes: > [snip] >> I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing >> that the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org >> email. This can be configured repo-locally via: >> >> $ git config committer.email @gcc.gnu.org >> >> Git has supp

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Jonathan Wakely via Gcc
On Tue, 25 Jun 2024 at 10:06, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: > > Hi, > > Andrew Stubbs writes: > > > On 24/06/2024 23:34, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: > >> I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing that > >> the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Richard Biener via Gcc
On Tue, Jun 25, 2024 at 12:36 AM Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: > > Hi, > > Sam James via Gcc writes: > > > Hi! > > > > This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally > > writing an RFC. > > > > What? > > --- > > > > I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, > > adding an

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Andrew Stubbs
On 25/06/2024 10:05, Arsen Arsenović wrote: Hi, Andrew Stubbs writes: On 24/06/2024 23:34, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing that the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org email. This can be configured repo-l

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Arsen Arsenović via Gcc
Hi, Andrew Stubbs writes: > On 24/06/2024 23:34, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: >> I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing that >> the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org email. >> This can be configured repo-locally via: >>$ git config commit

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-25 Thread Andrew Stubbs
On 24/06/2024 23:34, Arsen Arsenović via Gcc wrote: I was also proposing (and would like to re-air that here) enforcing that the committer field of each commit is a (valid) @gcc.gnu.org email. This can be configured repo-locally via: $ git config committer.email @gcc.gnu.org Git has supporte

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-24 Thread Arsen Arsenović via Gcc
Hi, Sam James via Gcc writes: > Hi! > > This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally > writing an RFC. > > What? > --- > > I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, > adding an extra field for their GCC/sourceware account: >account> > Joe

Re: [RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-24 Thread Jonathan Wakely via Gcc
On Mon, 24 Jun 2024 at 22:35, Sam James via Gcc wrote: > > Hi! > > This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally > writing an RFC. > > What? > --- > > I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, > adding an extra field for their GCC/sourceware account: >

[RFC] MAINTAINERS: require a BZ account field

2024-06-24 Thread Sam James via Gcc
Hi! This comes up in #gcc on IRC every so often, so finally writing an RFC. What? --- I propose that MAINTAINERS be modified to be of the form, adding an extra field for their GCC/sourceware account: Joe Bloggsjoeblo...@example.com jblo...@gcc.gnu.org Further,