Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Santafe
This is fun. Will have to watch it when I have time. Is there a large active genre just now combining ChatGPT wiht deepfakes, to generate video of whomeever-saying-whatever? I was thinking a couple of years ago about what direction in big-AI would be the most distructive, in requiring extra co

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Marcus Daniels
I have seen doctors run internet searches in front of me. If a LLM is given all the medical journals, biology textbooks, and hospital records for training, that could be a useful resource for society. -Original Message- From: Friam On Behalf Of Santafe Sent: Wednesday, March 1, 202

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Barry MacKichan
When I bought back my company about 25 years ago, the mantra for programmers was “Google the error message!” Now ChatGPT will write some of the code for you. The job of programming still requires a lot of knowledge and experience since using ChatGPT-generated code without quality checking is fa

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Marcus Daniels
Sure, but a doctor doesn’t need to take candidate diagnosis as anything more than a hypothesis. In M3gan (which I found to be more of a fun satire than a horror drama), the android is better able to counsel the child than the human guardian. That also seems plausible. All fiction and internet

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread glen
Yep, that's the fundamental problem with the "chat" usage pattern. But it's much less of a problem with other usage patterns. For example, we have a project at UCSF where we're using GPT3.5 to help us with the embeddings for full text biomedical articles. This produces opportunities for several

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Marcus Daniels
It seems to me the "mansplaining" is built into an algorithm that chooses the most likely response. Choose all responses above probability 0.9 and present them all to give the user a sense of the uncertainty. -Original Message- From: Friam On Behalf Of glen Sent: Wednesday, March 1,

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread glen
Exactly. We recently started a rough eval of the newer "text-embedding-ada-002" model versus the older "text-similarity-curie-001" model. The newer model produces a lower dimensional embedding (1536) than the older (4096), which could imply the older model might provide a more fine-grained [dis

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Marcus Daniels
On one hand, there needs to be ongoing debate (in training) to reflect actual uncertainty in responses. One the other hand, humans spew a lot of nonsense, and a lot of it is just wrong. That leads to the vulnerability to black hatters. If there is bias in the (peer) review of the input data

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Gillian Densmore
Glen Funny you say that about chat gpt: https://twitter.com/tasty_gigabyte7/status/1620571251344551938 On Wed, Mar 1, 2023 at 10:02 AM Marcus Daniels wrote: > On one hand, there needs to be ongoing debate (in training) to reflect > actual uncertainty in responses. One the other hand, humans s

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Marcus Daniels
It is pre-trained. Just because there is a chat doesn’t mean it considers the correspondent as providing new evidence. From: Friam On Behalf Of Gillian Densmore Sent: Wednesday, March 1, 2023 9:05 AM To: The Friday Morning Applied Complexity Coffee Group Subject: Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potte

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread glen
Right. I mispoke, "training" may not be the right word. But my understanding is they have humans monitoring at least some of the ChatGPT usage and using it for RL. I have no idea what the frequency of the feedback is, though. I speculate that it was much faster early on, when they effectively t

Re: [FRIAM] Magic Harry Potter mirrors or more?

2023-03-01 Thread Steve Smith
EricS - these are good observations... I believe it will lead to more and more value in *good curation* and a finer distinction on "authority through reputation".   I also believe that formal blockchain and/or some informal analog will become critical to authenticating sources.   I already fi

[FRIAM] Book Lovers of Santa FE

2023-03-01 Thread Steve Smith
I was just in Book Mountain which has been operating in SFe primarily as a paperback exchange since 1980 (just before I moved to the area) and discovered that the owner, Peggy Frank intends to shut down, probably sooner rather than later.  Here is an article about her move and rejuvenation of t

Re: [FRIAM] Book Lovers of Santa FE

2023-03-01 Thread glen
FWIW, if there were a lot of people interested in helping out a little bit, consider setting up a co-op. This store here in Oly did that soon after we moved up here. It was difficult because they transitioned, rather that constructed from scratch. https://www.orcabooks.com/co-op And I don't s

Re: [FRIAM] Book Lovers of Santa FE

2023-03-01 Thread Steve Smith
Excellent!   This is the kind of feedback I was fishing for.  I am reading some of Orca's materials on their CoOpness and can imagine that it is a hard thing to pull together without one or a very few strong personalities with the motivation to move it along crisply.   That is definitely not me

Re: [FRIAM] Book Lovers of Santa FE

2023-03-01 Thread Steve Smith
FWIW Searching this US worker-coop directory yielded 10 examples of coop bookstores and bookstores registered as "democratic workplaces" which I do not yet know the definition of: https://www.usworker.coop/directory/ Orca in Olympia is not listed which gives me the feeling that there may

Re: [FRIAM] Book Lovers of Santa FE

2023-03-01 Thread Steve Smith
Seems I missed a trick (or two) again... Peggy apparently started looking to be bought-out/partnered over 6 months ago and it is only now (after an acute health challenge?) that she seems to be on a mission to sell or shutter in short order. I'm futzing around with examples of people who have