Re: [FRIAM] 1. Is the Equal Sign Overrated? Mathematicians Hash It Out | WIRED (Tom Johnson)

2019-10-14 Thread Jon Zingale
Thanks Tom. It is exciting to see topos theory finding a place in the sun. When I was participating in Dan Freed's TQFT seminars at the University of Texas, we worked through one of Jacob's papers. Despite the seemingly all-pervasive mistrust of category theory (let alone topos theory), these semi

Re: [FRIAM] 1. Is the Equal Sign Overrated? Mathematicians Hash It Out | WIRED (Tom Johnson)

2019-10-14 Thread Frank Wimberly
In the work I did at CMU on statistical causal reasoning, we made heavy use of equivalence classes. Our algorithms would find equivalence classes of causal models (generalizations of acyclic digraphs). If any edge occurred in all elements of a class then it represented a cause between the variabl

Re: [FRIAM] 1. Is the Equal Sign Overrated? Mathematicians Hash It Out | WIRED (Tom Johnson)

2019-10-14 Thread Carl Tollander
I first became aware of the equality issue from a Barry Mazur paper http://www.math.harvard.edu/~mazur/preprints/when_is_one.pdf . The Robert Goldblatt book "Topoi The Categorical Analysis of Logic" has an honored place on my bookshelf but is mostly beyond me. I keep it because it covers a lot