Re: [FRIAM] All hail confirmation bias!

2019-07-28 Thread Nick Thompson
While we're getting rid of concepts, let's just get rid of this foolish, unsubstantiated concept, "the world." What sort of heuristic is THAT? N Nicholas S. Thompson Emeritus Professor of Psychology and Biology Clark University http://home.earthlink.net/~nickthompson/naturaldesigns/ -Orig

Re: [FRIAM] All hail confirmation bias!

2019-07-28 Thread David Eric Smith
I think Ortega y Gasset had things to say about that in Man and Crisis. I haven’t read enough to know yet whether I think his take is important. But it would be hard to find someone who picked up the question in terms more identical to those that Nick uses below to frame it. Eric > On Jul 2

Re: [FRIAM] Posts from the Scotts

2019-07-28 Thread Steven A Smith
glen∈ℂ wrote: > The 3 excerpts below seem to indicate the (my?) problem. At first, I > though Marcus was agreeing with me by listing options for > harm-of-eating-animals. But then he goes toward monism-by-unification > with "agreeing on what matters" and > whole-equilibrium-implies-part-equilibriu

Re: [FRIAM] Posts from the Scotts

2019-07-28 Thread Marcus Daniels
Steve writes: I'm reminded of a book (long misplaced) I inherited from my grandfather's library (born in 1898) who was for a modest time (<10 years) the principal of a High School. The book's title was "Straight and Crooked Thinking" and had a modest amount of marginalia in his (I

Re: [FRIAM] All hail confirmation bias!

2019-07-28 Thread Nick Thompson
Eric, Can you direct me to any particular passages or chapters in the book? I am unlikely to read the whole thing, but I want to know your thought. I rummaged around in the Books.google site for a bit and found this: If so, I don’t think I was saying anything this profound.

[FRIAM] Predictive coding basedon deep learning

2019-07-28 Thread Steven A Smith
Anyone here who codes regularly (daily?) who thinks this is useful?   As an aging has-been, I can see how it could extend my semi-competence quite a long way... but could undermine something fundamental the way GPS seems to be undermining geospatial awareness and wayfinding skills? https://tabnin

Re: [FRIAM] Predictive coding basedon deep learning

2019-07-28 Thread Marcus Daniels
I think GPS increases geographical curiosity, not undermines it. This technology is objectionable for a different reason: A good software architecture compresses out every pattern into parameterized macro or higher order function. There should be no need to say anything more than once. Whet

Re: [FRIAM] All hail confirmation bias!

2019-07-28 Thread Prof David West
Nick stated: "I deplore a skepticism that drinks only 9/10ths of the potent, and then puts the glass down, burps, and walks away with a smug look on its face." Excepting the mystic who recognizes that "ALL is illusion," has anyone drunk the full potent? davew On Sun, Jul 28, 2019, at 9:23 PM

Re: [FRIAM] All hail confirmation bias!

2019-07-28 Thread Marcus Daniels
< I deplore a skepticism that drinks only 9/10ths of the potent, and then puts the glass down, burps, and walks away with a smug look on its face. > One fix I’ve observed to exist in an actual medical protocol is to make the dose adequate for a 100 kilogram man. A 50 kilogram woman will get