Re: Request for feedback on TCP security (IETF effort)

2010-03-08 Thread Fernando Gont
Qing, The reason for which I posted this note here was to get *technical* input on the contents of the I-D. So far 99% of the discussion in TCPM has been around whether to accept this document as a wg item or not, whether to change the outline or not, etc. (i.e., "procedural discussions", if you

RE: Request for feedback on TCP security (IETF effort)

2010-03-07 Thread Li, Qing
I have been monitoring the tcpm ML debate about this draft for the past year. Frankly for the past two months the volume of tinygrams on the subject is so overwhelming I stopped reading any email relating to this topic. I think Mark Allman's email titled "TCPM" posted on March 2 put things into p