Re: De-orbitting mrouted

2006-09-28 Thread Bruce M Simpson
Bill Fenner wrote: I think it would be a good idea if we de-orbit /usr/sbin/mrouted in 7-CURRENT. Do it. Maybe consider making a port if anyone cares to continue to use it. (Gee, I suppose I could do that part ;-) I count +3 votes in favour. As soon as I get some spare cycles (juggli

Re: De-orbitting mrouted

2006-09-28 Thread Bill Fenner
>I think it would be a good idea if we de-orbit /usr/sbin/mrouted in >7-CURRENT. Do it. Maybe consider making a port if anyone cares to continue to use it. (Gee, I suppose I could do that part ;-) Bill ___ freebsd-net@freebsd.org mailing list http

Re: De-orbitting mrouted

2006-09-28 Thread Bruce M Simpson
John Hay wrote: Well what is there to do ipv4 multicast routing then? For ipv6 I have been using the net/mcast-tools package with pim6sd and pim6dd, but it seems that we are a bit thin in the ipv4 field... net/xorp maybe, although it looks like an overkill... I haven't tried it myself though.

Re: De-orbitting mrouted

2006-09-28 Thread John Hay
On Thu, Sep 28, 2006 at 10:55:29AM +0100, Bruce M Simpson wrote: > Hi, > > I think it would be a good idea if we de-orbit /usr/sbin/mrouted in > 7-CURRENT. Several reasons: > > 1. DVMRP is not specified for any new multicast installations; PIM is > the de-facto standard now. > 2. The code gener

Re: De-orbitting mrouted

2006-09-28 Thread Andre Oppermann
Bruce M Simpson wrote: Hi, I think it would be a good idea if we de-orbit /usr/sbin/mrouted in 7-CURRENT. Several reasons: 1. DVMRP is not specified for any new multicast installations; PIM is the de-facto standard now. 2. The code generates warnings during a buildworld (see bin/71633) 3. G

De-orbitting mrouted

2006-09-28 Thread Bruce M Simpson
Hi, I think it would be a good idea if we de-orbit /usr/sbin/mrouted in 7-CURRENT. Several reasons: 1. DVMRP is not specified for any new multicast installations; PIM is the de-facto standard now. 2. The code generates warnings during a buildworld (see bin/71633) 3. Given point (1) it probab