Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Ernie Luzar
Michael Grimm wrote: Sebastián Maruca via freebsd-jail wrote: Now we're talking about 10.3-HEAD wiht Jails+vnet... but then again, has anyone tried it? Roger, it seems you are thumbing up my challenge... But I guess i'll have to stick with netgraph instead epair/if_bridge because the later i

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Sebastián Maruca via freebsd-jail
Michael... even though you consider yourself as a admin hobbier, I can tell you have the "lend hander" top grade you're honored ;) I'll start from this big step you're posting (and all the other which replied too) and carry on dancing 'til I got my jails running DMZ, VLAN and WAN like a pro... B

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Kai Gallasch
On 01.06.2016 18:07 Roger Marquis wrote: > Ernie Luzar wrote: >> the kernel to included vimage. Enabling pf or ipf firewalls cause the >> host to crash. ipfw firewall does not cause a crash but has next to no >> real life usage on vimage. > Vimage gets little attention. Unfortunately the mapping

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Michael Grimm
Sebastián Maruca via freebsd-jail wrote: > Now we're talking about 10.3-HEAD wiht Jails+vnet... but then again, has > anyone tried it? Roger, it seems you are thumbing up my challenge... > But I guess i'll have to stick with netgraph instead epair/if_bridge because > the later is not so documen

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread markham breitbach
>> I disagree with you about the security issue of using localhost. Running >> sendmail in a non-vimage jail using its default config listening on >> localhost is still contained in the jail. Localhost is internally >> converted to the jails assigned ip address by jail(8). > How is anything listen

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Roger Marquis
Well... The spirit of this post inspires me the good way! Now we're talking about 10.3-HEAD wiht Jails+vnet... but then again, has anyone tried it? Roger, it seems you are thumbing up my challenge... All I would add is "test, test, test". If that goes well, and I'd expect it would, implement i

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Roger Marquis
>> Ernie Luzar wrote: >> Considering we have had ipfw/vimage/netgraph jails for several years I'd >> be interested in your data sources. > > The source is personal experience. Tested 9.3 & 10.0 with ipfw running > in vnet/vimage jails. At that time ipfw was logging to the host and not > to the vima

Re: deploy multiple vnets with VIMAGE/VNET + Production Ready?

2016-06-02 Thread Ernie Luzar
Roger Marquis wrote: Ernie Luzar wrote: the kernel to included vimage. Enabling pf or ipf firewalls cause the host to crash. ipfw firewall does not cause a crash but has next to no real life usage on vimage. Considering we have had ipfw/vimage/netgraph jails for several years I'd be interested