Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-25 Thread Nick Hibma
> While this can be moved into the man page, I don't see how a > message like this can significantly slow down booting, unless you have a > slow serial console. However, a pointer is still useful; I'd suggest a > shorter message like: > > ad0: DMA disabled: See ad(4) man page for possible

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-23 Thread Alex Zepeda
On Wed, 22 Dec 1999, Soren Schmidt wrote: > > ad0: ATA-4 disk at ata0 as master > > ad0: 12416MB (25429824 sectors), 25228 cyls, 16 heads, 63 S/T, 512 B/S > > ad0: 16 secs/int, 1 depth queue, UDMA33 > > ... > > > > Although I coulda sworn it was an ATA/66 device with the proper cable. > > Hmm.

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-23 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Pim van Grol wrote: > Good job, the latest revision works, allthough in DMA mode. Thanks! > By the way, my motherboard (Epox EP-51MVP3G-M) indeed supports a > 82c596 as south bridge, containing a (82c)571 device as IDE controller. > From dmesg: > > found-> vendor=0x1106, dev=0x0

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Darryl Okahata
Soren Schmidt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It seems Nick Hibma wrote: > > > If you end up doing this, can you have the driver print a line letting > > > people know this is intentional? i.e., > > > > > > ad0: DMA disabled: This drive does not properly support DMA mode. > > > ad0: To force DMA

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Jeroen C. van Gelderen
Nick Hibma wrote: > > > If you end up doing this, can you have the driver print a line letting > > people know this is intentional? i.e., > > > > ad0: DMA disabled: This drive does not properly support DMA mode. > > ad0: To force DMA for this drive (at your own risk) set flags 0xXX. > > Let's n

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Nick Hibma wrote: > > > Mentioning it in the manpage should be sufficient I guess. Blacklisting > > > devices sounds like a good idea if tey fail to work correctly in many > > > cases. > > > > The problem being how to get a list that is "good enough" for the > > majority of cases. > > I

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Nick Hibma
> > Mentioning it in the manpage should be sufficient I guess. Blacklisting > > devices sounds like a good idea if tey fail to work correctly in many > > cases. > > The problem being how to get a list that is "good enough" for the > majority of cases. I'd like to see it the other way around: Mak

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Nick Hibma wrote: > > If you end up doing this, can you have the driver print a line letting > > people know this is intentional? i.e., > > > > ad0: DMA disabled: This drive does not properly support DMA mode. > > ad0: To force DMA for this drive (at your own risk) set flags 0xXX. >

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Nick Hibma
> If you end up doing this, can you have the driver print a line letting > people know this is intentional? i.e., > > ad0: DMA disabled: This drive does not properly support DMA mode. > ad0: To force DMA for this drive (at your own risk) set flags 0xXX. Let's not go the Linux way and make the

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Pim van Grol wrote: > For your information: > > I encountered the same problem on a MVP3 board (Epox ep-mvp3g-m) > with via vt82c596, which worked well untill 13-12-99. Matrox HD. Are you sure you mean 596 ?? that is NOT supported (yet). > Correctly interpreted as doing UDMA33. From ve

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-22 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Alex Zepeda wrote: > > Perhaps blacklisting all WD/Maxtor drives that don't report an ATA > version, as the ata (and wd) driver works flawlessly in UDMA33 mode with > my setup: Hmm, thats an idea... > ata-pci0: at device 7.1 on pci0 > ata-pci0: Busmastering DMA supported > ata0 at 0x0

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Alex Zepeda
On Tue, 21 Dec 1999, Soren Schmidt wrote: > It probably because I relaxed the requirements for doing WDMA on disks > that doesn't bother to tell whihc verson of the ATA spec they conform to. > I think your case is the more seldom one, but I'm this close to > blacklisting all WD/Maxtor drives, tha

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Matthew Dillon wrote: > > The thread 'vm_page_remove panic' that Tamiji Homma initiated may be > related. She is getting a panic in the buffer cache subsystem while > using the new ATA driver with softupdates + NFS exported filesystems. > > I do not know if it is relat

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Peter Wemm wrote: > > Same here, but with a toshiba laptop disk. I have to comment out a version > test in ata-disk.c to get it to work. I've just a few hours ago committed a change that does this... > > --- ata-disk.c 1999/12/18 20:06:30 1.46 > +++ ata-disk.c 1999/12/21 21:48:2

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Matthew Dillon
:> it broke again as I recompiled my system yesterday (This was the first :> time after it had been fixed, so I don't know when exactly it broke). :> :> Harddisks: Western Digital Caviar (2.0 GB), non-DMA and :>Western Digital Caviar (2.5 GB), DMA-33. :> Mainboard: Asus P5A-B Super7 :

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Peter Wemm
Theo van Klaveren wrote: > > When installing the 08-dec-1999 snapshot (before ATA went in GENERIC), > a recompile from the kernel with the ATA driver instead of the WD > driver resulted in an unbootable system because of the following > error (approx.): > > mounting root /dev/ad0s1a > ata-mast

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Doug White wrote: > > > > It probably because I relaxed the requirements for doing WDMA on disks > > that doesn't bother to tell whihc verson of the ATA spec they conform to. > > I think your case is the more seldom one, but I'm this close to > > blacklisting all WD/Maxtor drives, that w

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Doug White
On Tue, 21 Dec 1999, Soren Schmidt wrote: > > Harddisks: Western Digital Caviar (2.0 GB), non-DMA and > >Western Digital Caviar (2.5 GB), DMA-33. > > Mainboard: Asus P5A-B Super7 > > Chipset: ALi Aladdin V AGPset > > It probably because I relaxed the requirements for doing WDMA on di

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Richard J Kuhns
Soren Schmidt writes: > It seems Theo van Klaveren wrote: > > On Tue, 21 Dec 1999, Soren Schmidt wrote: > > > > > > Harddisks: Western Digital Caviar (2.0 GB), non-DMA and > > > >Western Digital Caviar (2.5 GB), DMA-33. > > > > Mainboard: Asus P5A-B Super7 > > > > Chipset: ALi

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Theo van Klaveren wrote: > On Tue, 21 Dec 1999, Soren Schmidt wrote: > > > > Harddisks: Western Digital Caviar (2.0 GB), non-DMA and > > >Western Digital Caviar (2.5 GB), DMA-33. > > > Mainboard: Asus P5A-B Super7 > > > Chipset: ALi Aladdin V AGPset > > > > It probably becau

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Theo van Klaveren
On Tue, 21 Dec 1999, Soren Schmidt wrote: > > Harddisks: Western Digital Caviar (2.0 GB), non-DMA and > >Western Digital Caviar (2.5 GB), DMA-33. > > Mainboard: Asus P5A-B Super7 > > Chipset: ALi Aladdin V AGPset > > It probably because I relaxed the requirements for doing WDMA on di

Re: Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Soren Schmidt
It seems Theo van Klaveren wrote: > > When installing the 08-dec-1999 snapshot (before ATA went in GENERIC), > a recompile from the kernel with the ATA driver instead of the WD > driver resulted in an unbootable system because of the following > error (approx.): > > mounting root /dev/ad0s1a >

Problems with the ATA-driver

1999-12-21 Thread Theo van Klaveren
When installing the 08-dec-1999 snapshot (before ATA went in GENERIC), a recompile from the kernel with the ATA driver instead of the WD driver resulted in an unbootable system because of the following error (approx.): mounting root /dev/ad0s1a ata-master: lost disk contact ata: resetting devi