Re: [Foundation-l] Re: [Wikizh-l] About WM priv ate policy

2010-12-24 Thread Thomas Dalton
On 24 December 2010 23:20, Dan Rosenthal wrote: > Addressing the other half of this issue, "is creating a page = to editing", > I'd argue that page creation is a subset of editing with a fundamental > difference. Creating a page has different requirements (such as meeting > mandatory inclusion

Re: [Foundation-l] Re: [Wikizh-l] About WM priv ate policy

2010-12-24 Thread Dan Rosenthal
Addressing the other half of this issue, "is creating a page = to editing", I'd argue that page creation is a subset of editing with a fundamental difference. Creating a page has different requirements (such as meeting mandatory inclusion requirements, like notability, or local project rules) th

Re: [Foundation-l] Re: [Wikizh-l] About WM priv ate policy

2010-12-24 Thread Andrew Gray
On 24 December 2010 10:20, HW wrote: >> A recent discussion on zh Wikipedia is talking about the WMF private policy >> which is on http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_policy . Some IP user >> says that in the sentence "The Foundation does not require editors to >> register >> with a proj

[Foundation-l] Re: [Wikizh-l] About WM priv ate policy

2010-12-24 Thread HW
Is WMF approved that??? 寄件人﹕ Liangent 收件人﹕ 中文维基百科邮件列表/中文維基百科郵件列表/Mailing list for 傳送日期﹕ 2010/12/24 (五) 2:40:23 PM 主題: Re: [Wikizh-l] About WM private policy Note that creating page without logging in is also banned in enwiki. On Fri, Dec 24, 2010 at 10:19 AM,