[exim] Follow-Up: options trust-ad

2024-07-15 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hi, I just updated the github wiki page The text was: **If**, and _only_ if, the DNS resolver does not validate by default, then you need to ensure that your queries are marked as requiring DNSSEC. On some platforms, this can be done with an option in `/etc/resolv.conf` but in all cases, in Exi

[exim] Re: GnuTLS and Dane-Problem finally solved

2024-07-14 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello Viktor, Hello Andrew, looks like, I have not clearly enough stated in my last mails, that SNI is not longer an issue. After the options trust-ad thing, and restarting everthing, SNI worked. > Red herring, due to a flawed test. The SNI issue remains unresolved. And in the meanwhile Andrew

[exim] Re: GnuTLS and Dane-Problem finally solved

2024-07-13 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
-- In Antwort auf die folgende Mail From: Andrew C Aitchison via Exim-users To: Wolfgang Cc: exim-users@lists.exim.org Subject: [exim] Re: GnuTLS and Dane-Problem finally solved Date:Sat, 13 Jul 2024 21:08:44 +0100 (BST) >> >> Ok, I compared the the certs again and they just look

[exim] GnuTLS and Dane-Problem finally solved

2024-07-13 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello Viktor, Hello Jeremy, and all others helping me, to find the problem with my exim not able to deliver to the https://blog.lindenberg.one/EmailSecurityTest . I tried now a lot of things, and learned a lot about debugging this kind of error. As the biggest problem lies into the test-mecha

[exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!

2024-07-08 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Viktor Dukhovni via Exim-users To: exim-users@lists.exim.org Cc: Subject: [exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS! Date:Mon, 8 Jul 2024 23:29:40 +1000 On Mon, Jul 08, 2024 at 03:02:35PM +0200, Wolfgang via Exim-users wrote: > >Perhaps the issue is as mundane as y

[exim] Re: no SNI used, when sending TLS secured messages out

2024-07-08 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello, to the Non-SNI Issue one question: Why is exim not using SNI for every TLS connection, which got established? SNI is helpful even far away from DANE for message routing, multiplexing MX and other stuff. If there are some caveats with this, there could be an option: HOSTS_AVOID_SNI, mayb

[exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!

2024-07-08 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello Viktor, thanks for your valuable assistance. >Author: Viktor Dukhovni via Exim-users >Date: 2024-07-08 04:30 +200 >To: exim-users >Old-Topics: [exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!, >[exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!, [exim] Re: >Problems wi

[exim] no SNI used, when sending TLS secured messages out

2024-07-07 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello, I just use another subject for the SNI issue, as this seems to be independent from the DANE-Problem with GNU-TLS. As it looks right now this causes the DANE-Problem, as the testserver gives another cert, when no SNI is sent and that cert reveals the problems with GNU-TLS. But now I have

[exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!

2024-07-07 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Thanks Viktor and Jeremy for your assistance! So Victor just told, that the SNI problem is related to the crypto fail problem. So for Jeremys questions: "exim -bP transport remote_smtp | grep dane" responds with: dane_require_tls_ciphers = hosts_require_dane = hosts_try_dane = * which shou

[exim] Re: Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!

2024-07-07 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello Jeremy, thanks for this very helpful hint! > Actual debug output from the Exim system. I pointed out how best > to do that on the 2nd (assuming that the Exim system is the > accepting end for the connection). > [ In case it's an outbound connection at issue, a simple way to get > debug

[exim] Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems it is GnuTLS!

2024-07-06 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello all, First a thanks to Viktor, for his mail with the excellent script, empowering openssl s_client! Second a short update, what I tested here: 1) SETUP NEW CLEAN TESTENVIRONMENT -- I have set up a virtual server with its own sub-domain, completly DANE,DKIM,

[exim] Follow-Up: Debug TLS/DANE problems / GnuTLS?

2024-07-05 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello, still trying to debug, why my exim is denying connection to mx06.lindenberg.one (see:https://blog.lindenberg.one/EmailSecurityTest ) I am much more familar with openssl, but debian-exim is linked against gnu-tls, so I started digging in gnttls binary tools also. Unfortunately gnutls-cli

[exim] Re: Problems with outgoing DANE-TLSA, when CA-anchored test fails

2024-07-03 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
On 2024-07-03 01:12, Viktor Dukhovni via Exim-users wrote: ... > It is time to post the actual certificate chain (without the private key > of course), or if this a remote server anyone can connect to, > alternatively the hostname (and port, if not 25) of the remote server. > > The information yo

[exim] Re: Debug TLS/DANE problems

2024-07-03 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello, On 2024-07-02 20:20, Jeremy Harris wrote: > > If that's all you added, it's because you didn't actually define an > option called "acl_smtp_starttls" - only an ACL called that. > > thanks, I knew, that I have missed something. But unfortunately that does not help, as I see now only som

[exim] Re: Debug TLS/DANE problems

2024-07-02 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello Chris, Thanks for your hint, but that does not work. I have already used openssl s_client to extract the whole certification chain, and I can confirm, that the DANE RR is valid. The DANE RR signs the key of the letsencrypt intermediate, which signs the cert, the MX uses. this last cert

[exim] Debug TLS/DANE problems

2024-07-02 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello all, to debug, why the valid CERT is not accepted for a DANE verified outbound connection, I tried to enable debugging via ACL: >acl_smtp_starttls: > accept > message = TLS debug started > logwrite = TLS debugging acl triggered > control = debug > c

[exim] Re: Problems with outgoing DANE-TLSA, when CA-anchored test fails

2024-07-02 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
On 2024-07-01 10:41, Viktor Dukhovni via Exim-users wrote: > On Sun, Jun 30, 2024 at 11:32:58PM +0200, Wolfgang via Exim-users wrote: > > > I have problems connecting DANE configured hosts, when the MX has a > > correct TLSA-RR but an valid certificate (letsencrypt) wit

[exim] Problems with outgoing DANE-TLSA, when CA-anchored test fails

2024-07-01 Thread Wolfgang via Exim-users
Hello, I have problems connecting DANE configured hosts, when the MX has a correct TLSA-RR but an valid certificate (letsencrypt) with the wrong CN. I cases with self-signed certs and correct TLSA-RR there are no problems. With the correct CN in an valid certificate and correct TLSA-RR everythin