[Emu] Proposal: SASL over EAP

2020-04-16 Thread Rick van Rein
.org/html/draft-vanrein-diameter-sasl-03 Looking forward to the EMU opinions, Kind regards, Rick van Rein InternetWide.org ___ Emu mailing list Emu@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/emu

Re: [Emu] Proposal: SASL over EAP

2020-04-18 Thread Rick van Rein
Hi Alan, >> An interesting usecase for EAP-SASL with all this would be WiFi and LAN >> authentication (EAPOL or 802.1x) passed over Diameter to *any* domain on >> the Internet, and receiving back tunnel information. > > Or RADIUS That's what everyone is thinking ;-) The reason for Diamete

Re: [Emu] Proposal: SASL over EAP

2020-04-18 Thread Rick van Rein
Hi, This is turning into a discussion about RADIUS versus Diameter. Please note that this is not implied by my proposal of SASL over EAP; that I merely want to be somewhat clear about how the use case could look. I do thank you for evaluating these details, and am aware that the anticipated adva

Re: [Emu] Proposal: SASL over EAP

2020-04-22 Thread Rick van Rein
Hi Alan / EMU, I'll try to talk to Paul @ SURF about Diameter <--> RADIUS; he runs Eduroam and I think he has mentioned Diameter before. Our use case is completely new anyway, so we have a free choice. Good to hear that EAP-SASL sounds implementable. We haven't built it, but I usually "mentally

Re: [Emu] Proposal: SASL over EAP

2020-04-22 Thread Rick van Rein
Jim, > [JLS] I am a bit surprised at hearing this is abandoned given that they > released an update of the software on the 20th of April I heard about stopping Moonshot years ago; this is newer info. -Rick ___ Emu mailing list Emu@ietf.org https://www

Re: [Emu] Proposal: SASL over EAP

2020-05-02 Thread Rick van Rein
the specific use case of Access Points. In conclusion, we have some work to do establish our identity system before EMU can be asked to look into this proposal. No problem, and thanks very much for considering the idea, Rick van Rein for InternetWide.org