On Jan 3, 2023, at 3:27 AM, Alexander Clouter wrote:
> ...and should continue to *not* show EAP Success/Failure for each inner
> method.
>
> For TEAP this is handled by the Intermediate-Result-TLV and *not*
> communicated via EAP-Payload-TLV.
That is... surprising.
> I think I actually trie
On Mon, 2 Jan 2023, at 21:20, Alan DeKok wrote:
>> It shows it for the *first* method but not subsequent methods.
>
> Ah.
>
> And it doesn't show the inner EAP authentication method finishing with
> EAP Success or EAP Failure.
...and should continue to *not* show EAP Success/Failure for each i
On Jan 2, 2023, at 3:45 PM, Alexander Clouter wrote:
> It shows it for the *first* method but not subsequent methods.
Ah.
And it doesn't show the inner EAP authentication method finishing with EAP
Success or EAP Failure.
> For later methods it shows:
>
><- Inter
On Jan 2, 2023, at 10:07 AM, Oleg Pekar wrote:
> [Oleg] I agree that this is a low priority remark, I just want to be sure
> that we don't leave any ambiguity here. The RFC 7170 implicitly says that
> after the peer replies with inner EAP Identity Response, and the server, for
> example, doesn'
On Mon, 2 Jan 2023, at 20:15, Alan DeKok wrote:
>> Appendix C.6 (Sequence of EAP Methods) will need to be updated to show this
>> too.
>
> The text has this, which seems sufficient:
>
> <- EAP-Request/
> EAP-Type=TEAP, V=1
>
On Jan 2, 2023, at 5:16 AM, Alexander Clouter wrote:
> I flagged earlier how EAP sequences are very poorly defined in general for
> any EAP method and for TEAP it is no different. I would like to see some
> language to help steer implementers in the right direction.
Very much so, yes.
> To i
>> 1) Section "3.3.1. EAP Sequences"
>> It says "Upon completion of each EAP method in the tunnel, the server
MUST send an Intermediate-Result TLV...". We have discussed previously that:
>> a) EAP RFC 3748 calls EAP types 1..3 also "EAP methods":
>This is address with discussion in commit
https:
On Sat, 31 Dec 2022, at 17:14, Oleg Pekar wrote:
> Few initial comments:
>
> [snipped EAP sequences scene setting]
>
> Thus we considered in one of the previous discussions to say in Section 3.3.1
> of TEAP "Upon completion of each EAP __authentication__ method in the tunnel,
> the server MUST
On Dec 31, 2022, at 12:14 PM, Oleg Pekar wrote:
>
> Hi all,
> Few initial comments:
> 1) Section "3.3.1. EAP Sequences"
> It says "Upon completion of each EAP method in the tunnel, the server MUST
> send an Intermediate-Result TLV...". We have discussed previously that:
> a) EAP RFC 374
Hi all,
Few initial comments:
1) Section "3.3.1. EAP Sequences"
It says "Upon completion of each EAP method in the tunnel, the server MUST
send an Intermediate-Result TLV...". We have discussed previously that:
a) EAP RFC 3748 calls EAP types 1..3 also "EAP methods":
6.2. Method Types
The
10 matches
Mail list logo
