Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff
Gys, please don't start a flamewar out of nowhere! Jose: Thanks for your proposal! Libmutter does indeed implement a Wayland compositor and it's the Glib equivalent of Qt's compositor module. Migration to Mir does not make sense for us because Mutter and even GTK are not natively supported by

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread José Expósito
I didn't say that, I only proposed a new project to add new features to eOS, the eOS developers say no... So end of the conversation, their project their rules ;) Feel free to answer this email (I'd suggest you to read some documentation about the status of the implementation in both toolkits and

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread dardevelin
You should know better, X11, Mir, Wayland ALL are abstracted by the toolkits. So I am sorry my useless words caught up your Qt Agenda. So far I have only seen you say 'We should use Qt + Wayland not Gtk + Mir because I know it better' even though it doesn't matter because they are abstracted. On

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread José Expósito
> As far as I know, Mutter does run on Wayland. So I'm not sure it makes > sense to write a brand new compositor when we could continue to use > Gala. Great, I didn't know that libmutter already implements the Wayland protocol, those are good news and, in this situation a new compositor doesn't ma

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread dardevelin
Jose, wayland is just a protocol. Toolkits abstract the display server and they may or may not implement wayland. In fact wayland has a design that decouples multiple things that were all in on solution under X11 including the compositor, where Weston is the reference compositor. So I am sorry b

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread Daniel Foré
Hey José, As far as I know, Mutter does run on Wayland. So I'm not sure it makes sense to write a brand new compositor when we could continue to use Gala. But yes, I think right now it makes the most sense for us to be thinking Wayland instead of Mir. Cheers, Daniel Foré elementaryos.or

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread José Expósito
I was not talking about porting all the apps to Qt, actually this is not necessary you can run GTK+ apps over a Qt Wayland compositor without any problems, I was talking about write *one* app using Qt. But if for some good reason you don't want to include Qt in the default CD image (to save a coup

[Elementary-dev-community] Wayland plans? Here is a proof of concept compositor :)

2014-06-06 Thread José Expósito
Hi all, I was wondering what are the plans of the eOS team about Wayland. Are you choosing Wayland or Mir? Personally speaking, I think that Wayland is the correct option here for a lots of reasons, so I made a proof of concept C++/QML compositor that looks like [1]. I know that elementary OS re