Re: [DNSOP] new EDE draft with a few changes

2020-01-15 Thread Wes Hardaker
Eric Orth writes: > Here is the text I suggested on 2019-12-02: "Long EXTRA-TEXT fields may cause > truncation and bad > resolve performance, which is usually undesirable for the supplemental nature > of EDE. Operators > setting the field SHOULD avoid setting unnecessarily long contents, > esp

Re: [DNSOP] new EDE draft with a few changes

2019-12-25 Thread Wes Hardaker
Eric Orth writes: > Regarding TC-bit: I would still prefer adding a sentence or two that error > generators should keep > the EXTRA-TEXT field short to minimize the need for truncation. Seems reasonable. I'll need to go back and find your text since I don't remember it specifically. But I'll

[DNSOP] new EDE draft with a few changes

2019-12-18 Thread Wes Hardaker
Folks, Per the discussions in the past about both the TC bit and resolver/forwarding, I've updated the draft with the following text for these two issues. Below is a new section that describes these issues. I *believe* that this might be a good enough middle ground to get us past rough consensu