Re: [DNSOP] Root reasons (aka "why") - HTTP vs SRV vs ANAME vs CNAME vs URI vs NAPTR

2018-11-09 Thread Brian Dickson
Patrik Fältström wrote: > Note changed subject... > > [rest of message cut from reply] There is a major semantic difference in the NAPTR/URI RDATA and how/where it is handled, which is at the HTTP application layer (i.e. 3xx rewriting). This differs from the other 4 RRTYPEs, where only the A/AAA

[DNSOP] Root reasons (aka "why") - HTTP vs SRV vs ANAME vs CNAME vs URI vs NAPTR

2018-11-09 Thread Patrik Fältström
Note changed subject... Sure, I think of course the URI RR is the best thing since sliced bread, but same for each one of the proponents of the other RRs. I think we could look at the various deployment scenarios and demonstrate what design features each one of the RRs have. And with such a des