Re: [DNSOP] Order of CNAME and A in Authoritative Reply.

2015-08-16 Thread Paul Vixie
this is "selling past the close", an error we are all here oft guilty of, but here i go anyway: Andrew Sullivan wrote: > IMO There is just an ambiguity in the RFCs, and I think it should be > fixed. yes. fundamentally, rrset ordering within answer sections needs clarification. noone disagrees. >

Re: [DNSOP] Order of CNAME and A in Authoritative Reply.

2015-08-16 Thread Andrew Sullivan
On Fri, Aug 14, 2015 at 07:45:09AM +1000, Mark Andrews wrote: > > RFC 1034 says to add to the answer. Not added to a list that will > then be compiled into a answer with possible reordering once all > the records have been collected. But as I already pointed out upthread, Mark, "add" does not me