I agree. At this stage, the ranking could do more harm than good, both for
developers and for users: can you imagine the consequences of giving diff
rating to mapserver,geoserver and deegree? Or to grass, gvsig and qgis?
All the best.
---
Paolo Cavallini
http://www.faunalia.it/pc
- Reply me
The ODF adoption/marketing committee of OASIS would be ever so annoyed about
your referencing ODF as the OpenOffice.org format as the whole point is that
OpenDocument is not a memory dump of an application converted to some vague
approximation of XML, but a genuine open standard which OpenOffice
Jason,
I agree that it is important that any rating system has had a lot of
thought put behind it, which is why I've suggested using the existing
OSGeo graduation rating system - which has had input from many of us in
the OSGeo community.
I do think that Andrea has highlighted a couple of add
I'm also not too keen on a star ranking system, especially if it is
mostly based on having passed incubation or not.
To me, passing incubation is more an indication of good process
management and long term viability than an indication of software
quality/robustness and ability to really solve
i think we need more "art" to the design template, this is more techical guy
marketing with OSGeo logo
we need more green to the templte
F
___
Discuss mailing list
Discuss@lists.osgeo.org
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss
Jason / Cameron,
>From the potential utiliser / implementer viewpoint:
I'd like to think that any project that has graduated OSGeo Incubation could be
considered a quality project with all of the vectors described by Andrea.
This proposed rating system implies that this may not be the case.
Co
You are going to have to ask Tyler for more detail. For my part I have seen
them handed out; raised a couple issues with respect to Font use, made an open
office template for slides and workbooks myself for foss4g and that is all
I know.
Jody
On 07/06/2010, at 5:48 AM, Jason Birch wrote:
On 07/06/10 05:29, Stefan Steiniger wrote:
what I miss:
- a line on supported platforms
- not sure if applicable to all: supported customization/scipting
languages (if not too geeky)
Good suggestions Stefan, I've added to the source Open Office doc here:
https://svn.osgeo.org/osgeo/livedvd/gi
Jody,
Is that under http://svn.osgeo.org/osgeo/marketing/flyer/ or is there
another source for it?
Jason
On 5 June 2010 19:40, Jody Garnett wrote:
> You should find that an official marketing template is already available as
> part of the work the graphics designed has done. My trouble is that
speaking for a project, i.e. OpenJUMP, that will probably not enter
OSGeo in the near future (its not that we don't want [we had a positive
vote for last year], but a lack of - volunteer - time to do the
necessary efforts and rather concentrate on improvements of the software):
I am fine with
Hei,
what I miss:
- a line on supported platforms
- not sure if applicable to all: supported customization/scipting
languages (if not too geeky)
and, I like it to be a OpenOffice doc, though Adobe Illustrator is fine
for me too.
stefan
___
Discu
11 matches
Mail list logo
