Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-14 Thread Derek Martin
On Tue, May 12, 2020 at 01:13:26PM -0400, Daniel Barrett wrote: > On May 11, 2020, Derek Martin wrote: > >> Dan Barrett wrote: > >>> 1. Store username/password pairs in a tab-delimited text file, one > >>> entry per line, with 3 columns: username, password, and freeform text. > > > >I do the same b

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-12 Thread Rich Pieri
On Tue, 12 May 2020 13:13:26 -0400 Daniel Barrett wrote: > Here's a scenario. I maintain a dozen MediaWiki sites, and each one > includes 1-2 mySQL passwords and several wiki user passwords. How > would you handle this situation with multiple, separately encrypted > password files? With a single

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-12 Thread Daniel Barrett
On May 11, 2020, Derek Martin wrote: >> Dan Barrett wrote: >>> 1. Store username/password pairs in a tab-delimited text file, one >>> entry per line, with 3 columns: username, password, and freeform text. > >I do the same basic idea but I use one file per password and >individually encrypt them. H

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-11 Thread Derek Martin
On Fri, May 08, 2020 at 03:08:52PM -0400, Steve Litt wrote: > On Fri, 8 May 2020 13:42:36 -0400 > Daniel Barrett wrote: > > Here is my password manager that seems to meet most of your > > requirements. > > > > 1. Store username/password pairs in a tab-delimited text file, one > > entry per line,

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-09 Thread Daniel Barrett
Oops, I missed a couple of your questions, Steve! On May 8, 2020, Steve Litt wrote: >I'm going to arrange for a piece of punctuation to be inserted when >creating the password. Most accounts require a punctuation in the >password, but they all differ as to *which* punctuation they allow. FWIW,

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-09 Thread Daniel Barrett
Steve Litt writes: >Daniel Barrett wrote: >> 3. Retrieve passwords using a simple script that calls gpg to decrypt, >> grep to find the line you want, and cut to isolate the username & >> password. Optionally, call xclip to copy username & password into the >> window manager's clipboard for easy p

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-08 Thread Steve Litt
On Fri, 8 May 2020 13:42:36 -0400 Daniel Barrett wrote: > On May 7, 2020, Tom Metro wrote: > >Here are the characteristics I consider minimum acceptable for a > >password manager: open source implementation; [...] code that only > >changes when I explicitly download and install a new version; [..

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-08 Thread Daniel Barrett
On May 7, 2020, Tom Metro wrote: >Here are the characteristics I consider minimum acceptable for a >password manager: open source implementation; [...] code that only >changes when I explicitly download and install a new version; [...] >good random password generator [...] no browser integration; n

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-07 Thread Tom Metro
> I use lastpass. It works on all platforms. Individual passwords are > encrypted as is the master password. Before giving advice on password managers its good to consider the type of user and the level of security required. Someone mentioned using a paper solution, and indeed that can be an accep

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-07 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 20:37:13 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: > Choose and deploy password in such a way that you can survive many > bugs. I'll counter with: you should stop making assumptions. First of all, this: > Which is near where we started. By having passwords so cumbersome > that they require con

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-07 Thread Jack Bennett
On Wed, May 6, 2020 at 6:59 PM Kent Borg wrote: > On 5/6/20 1:45 PM, Jack Bennett wrote: > > One of the benefits of a password manager is that it automates this > process > > so you can easily use passwords that would be impossible to remember > and/or > > type in (and lock them behind a suitable

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 9:44 PM, Doug wrote: > And even > then be really worried that, though your password software and how you > use it might be really, really excellent, if someone has spyware on your > machine that targets your password software, you are *so* screwed. > > This stuff is terrifying. Less so

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 7:32 PM, Kent Borg wrote: 16-random characters? Which? Let's assume just lower case ASCII alphabetics.  26^16 is 43608742899428874059776L That is a big number. (Add uppercase and numbers and other printable stuff...and 52**16 and 96**16 are both crazy bigger.) If your attacker st

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Doug
> And even > then be really worried that, though your password software and how you > use it might be really, really excellent, if someone has spyware on your > machine that targets your password software, you are *so* screwed. > > This stuff is terrifying. Less so if one uses two-step verificatio

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 8:37 PM, Kent Borg wrote: Choose and deploy password in such a way that you can survive many bugs. ...password software in such a way... -kb ___ Discuss mailing list Discuss@lists.blu.org http://lists.blu.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 8:26 PM, Kent Borg wrote: Which is near where we started. By having passwords so cumbersome that they require convenience-driven password management you are betting that your password manager software is, for some magical reason, bug-free. Choose and deploy password in such a way th

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 7:58 PM, Rich Pieri wrote: Proof against dictionary and rainbow table attacks against compromised account databases, Why do you care about rainbow attacks? Once a site is so badly compromised that an attacker the account database...what difference does it make if your plaintext pass

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 7:32 PM, Rich Pieri wrote: I have over 250 site passwords in my vaults. I can't remember and track them all. Therefore I have programs do it for me. Since I don't have to remember them all myself there is no need to constrain my passwords to memorable patterns. I'm not opposed to usin

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 19:32:49 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: > What is the point? Proof against dictionary and rainbow table attacks against compromised account databases, and making brute force atacks against my accounts take longer than the low hanging fruit. > Conversely, what is the cost? The cost is

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 1:58 PM, Doug wrote: I am not a security expert. I certainly would not notice the 2FA versus 2SV although now I see it is a real thing. What really impressed me and got me to take out the credit card after I read the article was that Google required all employees to use a Yubikey to do

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 1:58 PM, Rich Pieri wrote: You tell me why you think 16 random characters is inappropriate for this purpose. The reason for making passwords long is to make them unguessable. The key feature of a password is that, though I can make up guesses as fast as I choose to spend the money,

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 18:57:09 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: > I'm not opposed to software automatically generating passwords. But > why make them impossible to remember? I have over 250 site passwords in my vaults. I can't remember and track them all. Therefore I have programs do it for me. Since I don't

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 1:45 PM, Jack Bennett wrote: One of the benefits of a password manager is that it automates this process so you can easily use passwords that would be impossible to remember and/or type in (and lock them behind a suitable and memorable passphrase). I'm not opposed to software automati

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 15:30:03 -0400 Daniel Barrett wrote: > True, it's a black box, but it's a black box that world-class security > professionals have trusted: Around 4 years ago Yubi went closed source proprietary. Some of those professionals have since withdrawn their endorsements. -- Rich Pi

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Daniel Barrett
On May 6, 2020, Kent Borg wrote: >Yubikey feels more "Isn't this cool!?" to me than it feels secure. >Why should I trust it will only let me in? Why should I trust it >*will* let me in? True, it's a black box, but it's a black box that world-class security professionals have trusted: https://ww

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
I'm surprised I haven't seen anyone mention Teampass yet. It's functionally similar to Lastpass but it's self-hosted. -- Rich Pieri ___ Discuss mailing list Discuss@lists.blu.org http://lists.blu.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Doug
I am not a security expert. I certainly would not notice the 2FA versus 2SV although now I see it is a real thing. What really impressed me and got me to take out the credit card after I read the article was that Google required all employees to use a Yubikey to do their day-to-day jobs. For that r

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 13:42:08 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: > What are you trying to accomplish with these 16-random-characters? > That's only about 75-bits of entropy, so not a very good encryption > key, so you must mean password. So what are you trying to do? Stop a > brute force guessing foe? Give me

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Bill Cattey
I use KeePass as a password generator and safe.  It has Mac, Linux, Android, iOS ports that I have used. Specifically I use the KeePassXC port on my Linux laptops and Mac desktop, MiniKeePass on my iPad and KeePassDroid on my Android Phone. KeePass itself is Windows only. I've not actually run

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Jack Bennett
One of the benefits of a password manager is that it automates this process so you can easily use passwords that would be impossible to remember and/or type in (and lock them behind a suitable and memorable passphrase). Of course, this still requires trusting the creators of the manager applicatio

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 1:32 PM, Rich Pieri wrote: On Wed, 6 May 2020 13:05:58 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: Except 16+ is overkill for a password. (*Password*, not encryption passphrase--the two are extremely different uses.) Except... they're not. 16 random (I'm assuming) characters is what Google use for appli

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 13:05:58 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: > Except 16+ is overkill for a password. (*Password*, not encryption > passphrase--the two are extremely different uses.) Except... they're not. 16 random (I'm assuming) characters is what Google use for application passwords. Which are in fact

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 12:03 PM, Doug wrote: Am I wrong to presume everyone here uses 2-factor authentication? Yubikey is that, plus it has software that does try to figure out if the servers being contacted are the right ones, and not ones that just look right to a casual observer. You are wrong in the cas

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Daniel Barrett
On May 5, 2020, Doug wrote: >What if someone gets your Gmail account password? ... >This is why I spent $100 to get a pair of Yubikeys. Agreed! Protecting an account with a strong password and a Yubikey for the second factor is the best combo I've heard of.

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 11:16 AM, Rich Pieri wrote: On Wed, 6 May 2020 10:09:30 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: And for one that is reused...doesn't matter so much. All your uses are as weak as the weakest site to which you have given that password. Which is why 16+ random characters never reused. Except 16+ is o

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 12:03:41 -0400 Doug wrote: > Am I wrong to presume everyone here uses 2-factor authentication? Probably. To be nit-picky, common 2FA is actually 2SV (two-step verification). 2FA collquially is something you know plus something you have like an ATM PIN and the matching card. A

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Bill Ricker
On Tue, May 5, 2020 at 5:58 PM Jerry Feldman wrote: > I use lastpass. It works on all platforms. > LastPass is endorsed by Steve Gibson of Security Now! as being "Trust No One"; works with all major browsers and phones. They already had their minor security breach so have gotten past the obviou

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Doug
Am I wrong to presume everyone here uses 2-factor authentication? Yubikey is that, plus it has software that does try to figure out if the servers being contacted are the right ones, and not ones that just look right to a casual observer. On Wed, May 6, 2020 at 11:19 AM Rich Pieri wrote: > On We

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On Wed, 6 May 2020 10:09:30 -0400 Kent Borg wrote: > And for one that is reused...doesn't matter so much. All your uses > are as weak as the weakest site to which you have given that password. Which is why 16+ random characters never reused. Also, site operators cannot be trusted to report brea

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/6/20 9:57 AM, Kent Borg wrote: A password (if not reused between sites) does not have to be particularly strong. And for one that is reused...doesn't matter so much. All your uses are as weak as the weakest site to which you have given that password. -kb __

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-06 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/5/20 10:41 PM, Rich Pieri wrote: * Run: "pwgen -nsB ##" (where ## is typically 16 or more) Remember that there is a *big* difference between a password that is a password and one that is used for encryption. A password (if not reused between sites) does not have to be particularly strong.

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Rich Pieri
On Tue, 5 May 2020 20:27:03 -0400 Doug wrote: > One nice perk of lastpass: it will give you an overall security score > for every password you have. It took quite a bit of dull work over a > few weeks, but my security score is at 95%. The reason it is not > higher: shared passwords with the misse

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Doug
One nice perk of lastpass: it will give you an overall security score for every password you have. It took quite a bit of dull work over a few weeks, but my security score is at 95%. The reason it is not higher: shared passwords with the misses. Lastpass or 1Password are still not good enough. Wh

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Rich Pieri
On Tue, 5 May 2020 17:47:43 -0400 Jerry Natowitz wrote: > I've decided it is time to start using strong unique passwords on all > sites.  What products will work on Linux/gnu, Linux/Android, and > Windows 10?  Is the integration to the O/S, the window manager, or > the web browser?  Looking for

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/5/20 6:54 PM, Kent Borg wrote: The result is the passwords I use most frequently I remember, so I just type them. The ones I use infrequently are infrequent, so I don't mind looking them up. Remember: All software has bugs, password managers are not somehow immune. How about this analo

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Joe Polcari
FYI last pass will offer a long random secure password to you as an option Sent from my iPhone > On May 5, 2020, at 6:56 PM, Kent Borg wrote: > > On 5/5/20 5:47 PM, Jerry Natowitz wrote: >> I've decided it is time to start using strong unique passwords on all sites. > > Smart. > >> What pro

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Kent Borg
On 5/5/20 5:47 PM, Jerry Natowitz wrote: I've decided it is time to start using strong unique passwords on all sites. Smart. What products will work on Linux/gnu, Linux/Android, and Windows 10? Is the integration to the O/S, the window manager, or the web browser?  Looking for something tha

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Jack Bennett
I'm happy with 1Password It works seamlessly on everything I've tried it on: macOS, Ubuntu and Red Hat Linux, Windows 10. I'd be surprised if there weren't an Android app but you probably want to check that out to make sure. On Tue, May 5, 2020 at 5:50 PM Jerry Natowitz wrote: > I've decided it

Re: [Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Jerry Feldman
I use lastpass. It works on all platforms. Individual passwords are encrypted as is the master password. The only problem I had was when I forgot the exact spelling of my master pass phrase. Since my desktop system was logged in I was able to set another pass phrase. -- Jerry Feldman Boston Linux

[Discuss] Password managers

2020-05-05 Thread Jerry Natowitz
I've decided it is time to start using strong unique passwords on all sites.  What products will work on Linux/gnu, Linux/Android, and Windows 10?  Is the integration to the O/S, the window manager, or the web browser?  Looking for something that will work transparently across all the mentioned