Re: Slow shutdown with big file in /dev/shm

2012-03-20 Thread Bojan Smojver
On Tue, 2012-03-20 at 10:17 -0400, Adam Jackson wrote: > But it still seems to me like disabling > swap on shutdown is useless work. So, do I file this against initscripts or something else? -- Bojan -- devel mailing list devel@lists.fedoraproject.org https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/

Re: Slow shutdown with big file in /dev/shm

2012-03-20 Thread Adam Jackson
On 3/20/12 9:19 AM, Bojan Smojver wrote: Adam Jackson wrote: Now as to why we disable swap on shutdown, I'm not really sure. It certainly seems like useless work to me. Would it help if all memory based file systems got unmounted before swap gets disabled? That would kill these files, right?

Re: Slow shutdown with big file in /dev/shm

2012-03-20 Thread Michal Schmidt
Adam Jackson wrote: > Now as to why we disable swap on shutdown, I'm not really sure. It > certainly seems like useless work to me. We want to be sure we'll be able to stop/disassemble any block devices that are underneath it (RAID arrays etc.). Sure, if it's a simple partition, the work is usel

Re: Slow shutdown with big file in /dev/shm

2012-03-20 Thread Bojan Smojver
Adam Jackson wrote: >Presumably because that file got paged out. > >Think about it. Disabling swap doesn't know that the file exists only >on a RAM-based file system, and even if it did, doesn't know that we're > >about to shut down. So swapoff has to assume that any pages currently >in the s

Re: Slow shutdown with big file in /dev/shm

2012-03-20 Thread Adam Jackson
On 3/19/12 11:42 PM, Bojan Smojver wrote: Before I file a bug for this, I need to figure out which component may be doing this. If one creates a large file (several GB) in /dev/shm and shuts down, the system will take many minutes to shut down. Last message before hang is "Disabling swap". Not s

Slow shutdown with big file in /dev/shm

2012-03-19 Thread Bojan Smojver
Before I file a bug for this, I need to figure out which component may be doing this. If one creates a large file (several GB) in /dev/shm and shuts down, the system will take many minutes to shut down. Last message before hang is "Disabling swap". Not sure which component is doing that and why. T