Re: ABRT duplicate detection - is it for real?

2010-05-13 Thread Christoph Wickert
Am Donnerstag, den 13.05.2010, 15:17 +0200 schrieb Karel Klic: > Hi Christoph, > > there was a flaw in the duplicate detection (undiscovered for a long > time) that allowed to file that duplicates you received. > > It has been fixed. > > abrt.spec: > * Mon May 03 2010 Karel Klic 1.0.9-2 > - fi

Re: ABRT duplicate detection - is it for real?

2010-05-13 Thread Karel Klic
Dne 13.5.2010 14:55, Christoph Wickert napsal(a): > AFAIK abrt recognizes dupes based on hashes of the backtrace, but the > format of the backtraces has changed with nearly every new ABRT version, > so the backtraces will not be the same even from exactly the same crash. The hash is not calculated

Re: ABRT duplicate detection - is it for real?

2010-05-13 Thread Karel Klic
Hi Christoph, there was a flaw in the duplicate detection (undiscovered for a long time) that allowed to file that duplicates you received. It has been fixed. abrt.spec: * Mon May 03 2010 Karel Klic 1.0.9-2 - fixed crash function detection (a part of duplication detection) Karel Dne 13.5.201

ABRT duplicate detection - is it for real?

2010-05-13 Thread Christoph Wickert
I'm getting the same bug reports over and over again, for example https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=542393 Shouldn't ABRT catch the duplicates? AFAIK abrt recognizes dupes based on hashes of the backtrace, but the format of the backtraces has changed with nearly every new ABRT version,

Re: ABRT duplicate detection

2010-04-26 Thread Christoph Höger
Am Sonntag, den 25.04.2010, 19:56 +0200 schrieb Alexander Boström: > lör 2010-04-24 klockan 10:37 +0200 skrev Christoph Höger: > > > But if ABRT could detect duplicate crashes > > one could use this to display a workaround or even propose an update via > > packagekit. > > It could look in bodhi

Re: ABRT duplicate detection

2010-04-26 Thread Pekka Pietikainen
On Sun, Apr 25, 2010 at 09:33:40PM +0200, Radek Vokal wrote: > > You might all know the MS "search for a solution to this problem" window > > popping up after an application crashes. I've never seen it doing > > something usefull, though. But if ABRT could detect duplicate crashes > > one could use

Re: [Crash-catcher] ABRT duplicate detection

2010-04-26 Thread Jiri Moskovcak
On 04/25/2010 09:33 PM, Radek Vokal wrote: > 2010/4/24 Christoph Höger: >> Hi all, >> >> I was just wondering: How mature is ABRTs duplicate detection? >> >> You might all know the MS "search for a solution to this problem" window >> popping up after an application crashes. I've never seen it doing

Re: ABRT duplicate detection

2010-04-25 Thread Radek Vokal
2010/4/24 Christoph Höger : > Hi all, > > I was just wondering: How mature is ABRTs duplicate detection? > > You might all know the MS "search for a solution to this problem" window > popping up after an application crashes. I've never seen it doing > something usefull, though. But if ABRT could de

Re: ABRT duplicate detection

2010-04-25 Thread Alexander Boström
lör 2010-04-24 klockan 10:37 +0200 skrev Christoph Höger: > But if ABRT could detect duplicate crashes > one could use this to display a workaround or even propose an update via > packagekit. It could look in bodhi for packages which claim to fix the bug. "Would you like to test a proposed fix

ABRT duplicate detection

2010-04-24 Thread Christoph Höger
Hi all, I was just wondering: How mature is ABRTs duplicate detection? You might all know the MS "search for a solution to this problem" window popping up after an application crashes. I've never seen it doing something usefull, though. But if ABRT could detect duplicate crashes one could use thi