Re: Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-02 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
On 2012-10-02 6:17 PM, Bobby Holley wrote: The general problem as I see it is that talos try doesn't go orange if there's a regression (because we detect regressions over time), and checking the results against a baseline revision is kind of a pain, even with talos-compare. So I think most develo

Re: Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-02 Thread Bobby Holley
The general problem as I see it is that talos try doesn't go orange if there's a regression (because we detect regressions over time), and checking the results against a baseline revision is kind of a pain, even with talos-compare. So I think most developers ignore it, and those who have the gumpti

Re: Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-02 Thread Karl Tomlinson
Ehsan Akhgari writes: > Over in bug 796087, I'm proposing for us to remove the -t all try server > flag. The rationale is that the set of Talos tests vary greatly and most > of the people who test performance are only interested in a subset of Talos > tests. Frequently enough people change code

Re: Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-02 Thread Steve Fink
On 10/01/2012 04:40 PM, Jeff Hammel wrote: On 10/01/2012 04:32 PM, Ehsan Akhgari wrote: Over in bug 796087, I'm proposing for us to remove the -t all try server flag. The rationale is that the set of Talos tests vary greatly and most of the people who test performance are only interested in a

Re: Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-02 Thread Bobby Holley
I think this is a great idea. On Tue, Oct 2, 2012 at 1:32 AM, Ehsan Akhgari wrote: > Over in bug 796087, I'm proposing for us to remove the -t all try server > flag. The rationale is that the set of Talos tests vary greatly and most > of the people who test performance are only interested in a s

Re: Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-01 Thread Jeff Hammel
On 10/01/2012 04:32 PM, Ehsan Akhgari wrote: Over in bug 796087, I'm proposing for us to remove the -t all try server flag. The rationale is that the set of Talos tests vary greatly and most of the people who test performance are only interested in a subset of Talos tests. So I'm suggesting tha

Proposal to remove support for the -t all trychooser syntax

2012-10-01 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
Over in bug 796087, I'm proposing for us to remove the -t all try server flag. The rationale is that the set of Talos tests vary greatly and most of the people who test performance are only interested in a subset of Talos tests. So I'm suggesting that we should disallow -t all as it is a very eas