Re: Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-29 Thread Lars Francke
On Mon, Jul 29, 2019 at 2:46 PM Sean Owen wrote: > TL;DR is: take the below as feedback to consider, and proceed as you > see fit. Nobody's suggesting you can't do this. > > On Mon, Jul 29, 2019 at 2:58 AM Lars Francke > wrote: > > The way I read your point is that anyone can publish material (w

Re: Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-29 Thread Sean Owen
TL;DR is: take the below as feedback to consider, and proceed as you see fit. Nobody's suggesting you can't do this. On Mon, Jul 29, 2019 at 2:58 AM Lars Francke wrote: > The way I read your point is that anyone can publish material (which includes > source code) under the ALv2 outside of the AS

Re: Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-29 Thread Lars Francke
Happy to discuss this here but you're also invited to bring those points up at dev@training as other projects might have similar concerns. The request for assistance still stands. If anyone here is interested in helping out reviewing and improving the material please reach out. On Sat, Jul 27, 2

Re: Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-26 Thread Sean Owen
On Fri, Jul 26, 2019 at 4:01 PM Lars Francke wrote: > I understand why it might be seen that way and we need to make sure to point > out that we have no intention of becoming "The official Apache Spark > training" because that's not our intention at all. Of course that's the intention; the prob

Re: Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-26 Thread Lars Francke
Sean, thanks for taking the time to comment. We've discussed those issues during the proposal stage for the Incubator as others brought them up as well. I can't remember all the details but let me go through your points inline. My reservation here is that as an Apache project, it might appear to

Re: Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-26 Thread Sean Owen
Generally speaking, I think we want to encourage more training and tutorial content out there, for sure, so, the more the merrier. My reservation here is that as an Apache project, it might appear to 'bless' one set of materials as authoritative over all the others out there. And there are already

Apache Training contribution for Spark - Feedback welcome

2019-07-26 Thread Lars Francke
Hi Spark community, you may or may not have heard of a new-ish (February 2019) project at Apache: Apache Training (incubating). We aim to develop training material about various projects inside and outside the ASF: < http://training.apache.org/> One of our users wants to contribute material on Sp