Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-10 Thread Asaf Mesika
> > I have selected these examples from the most recent discussions and they > may not be the best examples to fully illustrate the point. You should respect people's time by taking the time to craft your replies in this discussion. >From my experience, I've been contributing a lot in recent year

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-07 Thread Kalwit S
>> If you check the votes and the participation in discussion of PIPs it is *always* involving contributions of >3 different companies. >> Well, I think you've chosen *very* bad examples. In none of these cases the discussion I have selected these examples from the most recent discussions and they

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-07 Thread Dave Fisher
> On Mar 7, 2024, at 4:20 AM, Neng Lu wrote: > > BTW, if your team is really tired of managing a stable Pulsar, StreamNative > can help you :) And so can DataStax ;-)

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-07 Thread Neng Lu
I normally tend to be a silent observer of the community due to my limited time schedule. But I feel the obligation to share my thoughts in this thread so that people are not misled. > Most of the PIP monitoring involves adding plugins to existing > metrics APIs. He has also contributed to the PIP

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Yunze Xu
My fault for missing the discussion mails for these PIPs because I didn't check the archives of previous months. Thanks, Yunze On Thu, Mar 7, 2024 at 3:05 PM Lari Hotari wrote: > > On Thu, 7 Mar 2024 at 08:14, Girish Sharma wrote: > > There is for 310 - > > https://lists.apache.org/thread/13ncs

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Lari Hotari
On Thu, 7 Mar 2024 at 08:14, Girish Sharma wrote: > There is for 310 - > https://lists.apache.org/thread/13ncst2nc311vxok1s75thl2gtnk7w1t Girish, thank you for sharing the link to the PIP-310 thread. We also met in community meetings to discuss PIP-310 (https://lists.apache.org/thread/y1sqpyv37fo

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Joe F
> > know I’m not trying to be disrespectful, but it’s not respectful to be > biased and act like an expert during the reviews, while you’ve contributed > just for documentation PRs. When I talk about experience, I’m talking about > reviewers who don’t contribute to the project, they ask questions t

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Apurva Telang
Hello, Please find the discussion thread for PIP-337 on the Dev mailing list: https://lists.apache.org/thread/v4xh3fqy2t62xdk37b2ghvkrvvnqrx80 In the case of PIP-337, Lari was prompt in helping review the PIP and PR and providing valuable feedback. I acknowledged it via slack direct message to hi

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Girish Sharma
On Thu, Mar 7, 2024 at 11:38 AM Yunze Xu wrote: > Regarding PIP-332 and PIP 310, similar to PIP-337, there is no > discussion mail in the dev mail list. David left a comment [1] in > There is for 310 - https://lists.apache.org/thread/13ncst2nc311vxok1s75thl2gtnk7w1t Regards -- Girish Sharma

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Yunze Xu
Regarding PIP-332 and PIP 310, similar to PIP-337, there is no discussion mail in the dev mail list. David left a comment [1] in PIP-332 and there is no response. We can see discussions among Lari, Asaf and the author in PIP-310. And eventually PIP-310 is closed because the author has a different w

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Matteo Merli
On Wed, Mar 6, 2024 at 7:02 PM Kalwit S wrote: > I know I’m not trying to be disrespectful, but it’s not respectful to be > biased and act like an expert during the reviews, while you’ve contributed > just for documentation PRs. When I talk about experience, I’m talking about > reviewers who don’

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Yunze Xu
> Our team has also tried to submit multiple enhancements and also PIP, but most of them are bogged down by reviewers who are very new to Pulsar, might not understand messaging correctly, or don’t find such enhancements useful for their usecases. If your PRs or PIPs are not taken enough care of,

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Dave Fisher
> On Mar 6, 2024, at 10:01 PM, Kalwit S wrote: > > Also, Pulsar may have > numbers of non-SM PMC’s and committers, but if you look at the numbers over > the last 2-3 years, you’ll see that 99% are from SM. If you are saying that this is the proportion of new committers and PMC members in the

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Kalwit S
I know I’m not trying to be disrespectful, but it’s not respectful to be biased and act like an expert during the reviews, while you’ve contributed just for documentation PRs. When I talk about experience, I’m talking about reviewers who don’t contribute to the project, they ask questions to get to

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Joe F
I have not seen any specific asks or examples that give rise to these gripes, so it's all hypotheticals as of now. Please, as Enrico said, bring up specific issues. (1) How many reviewers (less than 1) have been involved in PIP review outside of the streamnative provider and how many of them have

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Matteo Merli
On Wed, Mar 6, 2024 at 12:49 PM Kalwit S wrote: > Thanks for your reply. But I wasn’t going to go after a specific person. I > Though that's precisely what your message was doing, in a very rude way. (1) How many reviewers (less than 1) have been involved in PIP review > outside of the streamna

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Enrico Olivelli
Kalwit, Il Mer 6 Mar 2024, 21:49 Kalwit S ha scritto: > Thanks for your reply. But I wasn’t going to go after a specific person. I > just wanted to point out this is an example of what we’ve been seeing for a > while now. And I wanted to point out why we’re not going to go with Pulsar. > Becaus

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Kalwit S
Thanks for your reply. But I wasn’t going to go after a specific person. I just wanted to point out this is an example of what we’ve been seeing for a while now. And I wanted to point out why we’re not going to go with Pulsar. Because if Streamnative is on the same trajectory as Confluent, then the

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Dave Fisher
> On Mar 6, 2024, at 4:50 AM, Lari Hotari wrote: > > Hi Kalwit, > > In Apache Pulsar, as in any other Apache project, everyone is equal > regardless of their committer or PMC status. All project participants > are free to express their opinions, and, where appropriate, have the > community co

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Dave Fisher
> On Mar 6, 2024, at 2:31 AM, Enrico Olivelli wrote: > > Kalwit, > All the committers are invited by the PMC, you can reach out to > priv...@pulsar.apache.org if you have any problems. > > Being a committer is not only about doing code contributions, but also > talking care of the project and

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-06 Thread Lari Hotari
Hi Kalwit, In Apache Pulsar, as in any other Apache project, everyone is equal regardless of their committer or PMC status. All project participants are free to express their opinions, and, where appropriate, have the community consider them when decisions are made. [1] I'm sorry to hear that you

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-05 Thread Enrico Olivelli
Kalwit, All the committers are invited by the PMC, you can reach out to priv...@pulsar.apache.org if you have any problems. Being a committer is not only about doing code contributions, but also talking care of the project and the community. I am sorry to hear that you feel that your contribution

Re: (Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-05 Thread Matteo Merli
I will not enter into debating the long list of grievances here, though I thought I needed to clarify at least 2 points: 1. You can ask any questions and direct any feedback to the PMC (and if you're not happy with the response you can take it all the way up to the ASF Board), but personal attacks

(Apache committer criteria) [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-05 Thread Kalwit S
Congratulations Asaf. Btw, does the Apache project have any promotion criteria for committers? I looked at Asaf's commits at https://github.com/apache/pulsar/commits?author=asafm and found that 99% of the commits are simple documentation changes and 1% are related to PIP monitoring. Most of the P

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-03-05 Thread Kalwit S
Congratulations.! On Tue, Feb 20, 2024 at 8:50 AM Lari Hotari wrote: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratulations, Asaf Mesik

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-26 Thread Ran Gao
Congratulations, Asaf! Best Regards, Ran Gao On 2024/02/20 16:50:29 Lari Hotari wrote: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratula

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-26 Thread PengHui Li
Congrats, Asaf. Penghui Li On Thu, Feb 22, 2024 at 8:17 PM Cong Zhao wrote: > Congratulations! > > Thanks, > Cong > > On 2024/02/20 16:50:29 Lari Hotari wrote: > > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-22 Thread Cong Zhao
Congratulations! Thanks, Cong On 2024/02/20 16:50:29 Lari Hotari wrote: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratulations, Asaf Mes

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-22 Thread Baodi Shi
Congrats! Asaf Thanks, Baodi Shi On Feb 22, 2024 at 15:12:50, Haiting Jiang wrote: > Congratulations! > > Thanks, > Haiting > > On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 9:35 PM Yubiao Feng > wrote: > > > Congratulations! > > > Thanks > > Yubiao Feng > > > On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 12:50 AM Lari Hotari wrote:

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-21 Thread Haiting Jiang
Congratulations! Thanks, Haiting On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 9:35 PM Yubiao Feng wrote: > > Congratulations! > > Thanks > Yubiao Feng > > On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 12:50 AM Lari Hotari wrote: > > > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asa

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-21 Thread Yubiao Feng
Congratulations! Thanks Yubiao Feng On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 12:50 AM Lari Hotari wrote: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratu

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-21 Thread Yike Xiao
Congrats! Asaf Yike Xiao > On Feb 21, 2024, at 18:55, houxiaoyu wrote: > > Congratulations! > > Best, > houxiaoyu > > Max Xu 于2024年2月21日周三 17:32写道: >> >> 👍Congratulations, Asaf! Well deserved. >> >> >> Best, >> Max Xu >> >> >>> On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 12:51 AM Lari Hotari wrote: >>> >>> The A

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-21 Thread houxiaoyu
Congratulations! Best, houxiaoyu Max Xu 于2024年2月21日周三 17:32写道: > > 👍Congratulations, Asaf! Well deserved. > > > Best, > Max Xu > > > On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 12:51 AM Lari Hotari wrote: > > > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asaf

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-21 Thread Max Xu
👍Congratulations, Asaf! Well deserved. Best, Max Xu On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 12:51 AM Lari Hotari wrote: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > We

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Zixuan Liu
Congratulations Asaf! Lari Hotari 于2024年2月21日周三 00:51写道: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratulations, Asaf Mesika! > > Please

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Nicolò Boschi
Congratulations! Nicolò Boschi Il giorno mer 21 feb 2024 alle 07:29 Zike Yang ha scritto: > Congratulations! > > BR, > Zike Yang > > On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 2:22 PM Hang Chen wrote: > > > > Congratulations Asaf! > > > > Best, > > Hang > > > > 太上玄元道君 于2024年2月21日周三 13:07写道: > > > > > > congrat

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Zike Yang
Congratulations! BR, Zike Yang On Wed, Feb 21, 2024 at 2:22 PM Hang Chen wrote: > > Congratulations Asaf! > > Best, > Hang > > 太上玄元道君 于2024年2月21日周三 13:07写道: > > > > congrats! > > > > Lari Hotari 于2024年2月21日 周三00:50写道: > > > > > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited >

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Hang Chen
Congratulations Asaf! Best, Hang 太上玄元道君 于2024年2月21日周三 13:07写道: > > congrats! > > Lari Hotari 于2024年2月21日 周三00:50写道: > > > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > > are pleased to announce that he has

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread 太上玄元道君
congrats! Lari Hotari 于2024年2月21日 周三00:50写道: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratulations, Asaf Mesika! > > Please join us in c

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Girish Sharma
Congratulations Asaf! On Tue, Feb 20, 2024 at 11:22 PM Julien Jakubowski wrote: > Congrats, Asaf! > > On Tue, Feb 20, 2024 at 5:51 PM Lari Hotari wrote: > > > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Julien Jakubowski
Congrats, Asaf! On Tue, Feb 20, 2024 at 5:51 PM Lari Hotari wrote: > The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited > Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we > are pleased to announce that he has accepted. > > Welcome and Congratulations, Asaf Mesika!

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Enrico Olivelli
Congratulations! Enrico Il Mar 20 Feb 2024, 18:08 Kiryl Valkovich ha scritto: > Congratulations, Asaf! > > From: Lari Hotari > Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 5:50 PM > To: dev@pulsar.apache.org > Subject: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mes

Re: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Kiryl Valkovich
Congratulations, Asaf! From: Lari Hotari Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 5:50 PM To: dev@pulsar.apache.org Subject: [ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to

[ANNOUNCE] New Committer: Asaf Mesika

2024-02-20 Thread Lari Hotari
The Apache Pulsar Project Management Committee (PMC) has invited Asaf Mesika https://github.com/asafm to become a committer and we are pleased to announce that he has accepted. Welcome and Congratulations, Asaf Mesika! Please join us in congratulating and welcoming Asaf onboard! Best Regards, L