Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-02-13 Thread Ritesh Shukla
Summary so far: 1. Community wide announcements and notifications via emails are best. 2. Community engagement on technical topics (stuff that search engines should be aware of) best done on GitHub Discussions 3. There should be community feedback around how to organize GitHub Discussions to better

Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-02-02 Thread Ethan Rose
> Currently this is shared in the docs folder in the ozone repo. Maybe you already talked about this, but once we move the docs content to the ozone-site repo (afaik that’s the plan) we will share these there, right? Will we have them published to the site? Thanks for bringing this up Zita, I have

Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-02-01 Thread Zita Dombi
Thanks for bringing this up! I agree with the ideas shared above. The way you shared the design proposal for container reconciliation is really good, it’s easy to give feedback and later to track back why some decisions were made. Currently this is shared in the docs folder in the ozone repo. Maybe

Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-02-01 Thread István Fajth
I tend to think that discussing design documents is absolutely fine in PRs and that they should be held alongside with the project. I see the benefit of possibly more effort going into keeping it up to date if it lives with the codebase. Still I welcome the suggestion from Ethan, to have an emphasi

Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-01-31 Thread Ethan Rose
Thanks for bringing up this proposal Ritesh. I am +1 for using GitHub Discussions for user/operational questions and indicating that on our Slack channel. I am also +1 for design discussions happening as PRs to markdown documents as we are doing for container reconciliation. Inline comments make i

Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-01-31 Thread Ritesh Shukla
Hi Pifta, Thank you for chiming in. I have actually not considered how to revive the mailing list for technical and design discussions. I am not sure why mailing lists are no longer as popular, in general I see a decline of using emails for discussions other than formal one way communication.

Re: RFC: Deprecate Slack and move to GitHub Discussions

2024-01-31 Thread István Fajth
Hi Ritesh, thank you for the proposal, and taking action during the last community sync. I support the idea of using GitHub Discussions, but I would like to bring up one thing with GH Discussions. I am not a fan of Slack either and I agree Slack is far from optimal and is hard to search. It did n