Important correction: *Thus, the max value of long does not have the
first bit as 1.*
On Mon, Nov 8, 2021 at 6:49 PM Kota Uenishi wrote:
>
> Hi Bharat,
>
> Thank you for the suggestion of object ID. By design, I understand
> that object ID is more suitable for delete table use case, regarding
> t
Hi Bharat,
Thank you for the suggestion of object ID. By design, I understand
that object ID is more suitable for delete table use case, regarding
the requirement for monotonicity. I took a glance on HDDS-4315 and I
have one question.
By looking the code, the object ID seems to have the most sign
Hi Kota,
>My question is that, is transaction index always available for non-HA
>cluster?
Yes, transaction index is available for non-HA also. But when you move from
non-HA to non-HA the transaction index starts again from 0, as it is a
newly setup cluster and ratis transaction index starts from
Thank you for the review, Lokesh and Bharat.
I understand that transaction id would be better than timestamp,
especially because the computation cost of getting timestamp. In this
case, requirement for the sorting of deletion keys has not to be
strictly monotonic, but just mild monotonicity, like
Hi Kota,
Thanks for taking up HDDS-5905 and quickly coming up with a design.
I liked the overall approach, but one thing instead of timestamps, I agree
with Lokesh, we can use transaction index, and also this will make
implementation easy. (As with timestamp, we need to propagate this from the
lea
Hey Kota
I really like the proposed approach because it makes sure that blocks are
deleted in order of key deletion. I would suggest using Ratis transaction id as
the prefix. I don’t think we will need a random suffix with that approach as
transaction id would avoid any collisions. Further it a
Hi Bharat & devs,
I've written up some of my idea to fix HDDS-5905, which is a
block-leak issue mentioned by Bharat. It involves some data format
change in deletion table, so I want to get broader range of feedback
from committers in addition to Bharat. If it looks good to you, I want
to start wri
