Invite to slack?

2025-03-04 Thread Harrison, Josh
Hello, The slack mentioned in the 2.2.0 README is locked down to people that have an apache.org email address, any chance I could get an invite? Thank you

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Russell Bateman
We're quite a ways back, but I do the development and I run on 1.28.1 (both NiFi and NiFi Registry). We have plans to move to 2.x someday. It's hard to get customers to move forward. On 3/4/25 10:22, Joe Witt wrote: What versions Russ? On Tue, Mar 4, 2025 at 10:15 AM Russell Bateman wrote:

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Chris Sampson
An alternative approach/future roadmap could be to consider integrating non-Git storage variants of the NiFiFlowRegistryClient into NiFi itself, e.g. the Filesystem, InMemory and Database variants from Registry itself. That would allow users to take advantage of all of the good work that's gone in

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Arpad Boda
Based on Shane's efforts to modernise NiFi Registry UI I would prefer to keep things as they are. I'm not aware of any concerns related to the backend, so in case Shane and other members of the community contributing to this effort can finish the works on the UI side I feel like there is going to b

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Chris Sampson
I am aware of environments where access to a Git server from the operational host/cluster that's running NiFi and NiFi Registry would not be available due to security or other constraints. Loss of a non-Git based Flow version control option would impact such environments. That said, I imagine such

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Lucas Ottersbach
Thank you for opening the discussion David. We also make use of the NiFi registry both for Flow versioning and automatic distribution of custom .nar artifacts to the clusters. We thought about moving Flow versioning to a Git provider to both: - profit from improved version history, and - investig

Re: Minimum provenance to keep nifi property

2025-03-04 Thread Mark Payne
Hi Kyle, There’s no minimum amount to keep - it will always keep everything that it can keep, up to the configured max. So in your case once you hit 10 GB of provenance events it will age off the older events to make room for newer events. And anything over 30 days will also be eliminated, for

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Russell Bateman
We don't use a separate Git repository; only the simple solution the NiFi Registry offers. Maybe someday we'll go further, but, in the meantime, It's super useful to us so we hope never to see it disappear. Thanks, Russ Bateman On 3/4/25 08:44, David Handermann wrote: Team, For more than two

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Joe Witt
What versions Russ? On Tue, Mar 4, 2025 at 10:15 AM Russell Bateman wrote: > We don't use a separate Git repository; only the simple solution the > NiFi Registry offers. > Maybe someday we'll go further, but, in the meantime, It's super useful > to us so we hope > never to see it disappear. > >

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Shane Ardell
Hello, I created this Jira [1] toward the end of last year in hopes of migrating NiFi Registry's UI similar to how we did for NiFi's UI. Aside from removing these outdated dependencies from the UI, this work leverages the shared component library that the new UIs share which results in a UX much c

Minimum provenance to keep nifi property

2025-03-04 Thread Nguyen, Kyle
Hi. Is there a “minimum provenance” to keep setting for a given processor? Use-case is 1. User asks us to check provenance on one of their “weekly” workflows (for data errors, etc.) 2. The “weekly” task’s provenance got deleted—perhaps from other, more frequently executed processors, du

Re: [DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread Joe Witt
David, First thanks for kicking off this thread. I think the punchline of what you wrote is "Current community work has focused on direct integration with Git-based Flow Registry Clients, including GitHub, GitLab, and BitBucket. With the Flow Registry Client as an extension point itself, the NiFi

[DISCUSS] Future maintenance plans for NiFi Registry

2025-03-04 Thread David Handermann
Team, For more than two years, the NiFi Registry project has received minimal maintenance attention. This is apparent from a review of commits related to the nifi-registry directory [1], the majority of which are incremental dependency version upgrades. As project maintainers, we need to decide on

I have two questions...

2025-03-04 Thread Simon Miller
Hi I need a couple of answers and have been unable to find them addressed anywhere. I have a working cluster of nifi 2.0.0m4 with tls, but I want to get oidc working. I finally figured to use admin identity to create a safe user to take over with an ldap/oidc login, however despite having server an