Re: [DISCUSS] Provided dependency on bcprov-jdk15on

2016-11-01 Thread Joe Witt
Mike Yep - that will need to get addressed/improved as well. First step is get the root classpath cleaned up again (NIFI-2971) and the next step is to understand and address the excessive declaration of dependencies which leads to duplication on such a scale. Thanks Joe On Tue, Nov 1, 2016 at 1

Re: [DISCUSS] Provided dependency on bcprov-jdk15on

2016-11-01 Thread Michael Moser
I would like to point out that some very common dependencies have been placed into the nifi-standard-services-api-nar. This nar is a Nar-Dependency-Id of several other nars. Many of these other nars also include the same dependencies, which would not be used by the nar class loader. In particula

Re: [DISCUSS] Provided dependency on bcprov-jdk15on

2016-11-01 Thread Aldrin Piri
I think in light of the fact that the bcprov item was an accidental inclusion and not explicitly meant to be handled as such in the framework reorganizing seems like the best option as well. The original intent of the PR was to minimize that footprint where we were double dipping given the inclusi

Re: Nifi ExecuteScript slow performance

2016-11-01 Thread balacode63
Thanks for the reply Joe, As matt suggested we moved to groovy. Thanks Bala -- View this message in context: http://apache-nifi-developer-list.39713.n7.nabble.com/Nifi-ExecuteScript-slow-performance-tp13735p13782.html Sent from the Apache NiFi Developer List mailing list archive at Nabble.co

Re: Nifi ExecuteScript slow performance

2016-11-01 Thread balacode63
Thanks for the reply matt, Jython is slow, As you suggested we moved to groovy. ExecuteScript is taking more than 2 seconds to execute below high level logic The logic: 1) Split data from flowfile 2) Query influxdb with splitted data (influxdb jar file used/external dependency) 3) write to influ

Re: FlowFile Package Spec

2016-11-01 Thread Joe Gresock
The Tar v1 format is actually quite nice for debugging purposes, since you can actually edit flow files in place on disk with VI, whereas the other flow file types cannot be easily edited once on disk. Our team has used this to quickly tweak and resubmit erroneous flow files that we capture on dis