Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-10-04 Thread Matthias J. Sax
A contributor should have the JIRA assigned to him/herself and thus should get notification about JIRA comments too, as if the JIRA is assigned, one also watches the JIRA. -Matthias On 10/4/17 1:32 PM, Ted Yu wrote: > The only thing missing is that the contributor needs to watch the JIRA > afte

Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-10-04 Thread Ted Yu
The only thing missing is that the contributor needs to watch the JIRA after sending out PR - otherwise he / she may miss comments on the JIRA (but not on PR). On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 12:27 PM, Matthias J. Sax wrote: > You can subscribe to single PR if you want, too. (That actually happens, > whe

Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-09-06 Thread Matthias J. Sax
You can subscribe to single PR if you want, too. (That actually happens, when you get tagged or comment on one, ie, you get auto subscribed to the PR.) There is a "Subscribe" button on the right hand side. -Matthias On 9/5/17 8:57 PM, Ted Yu wrote: > bq. I did get tagged or I did comment on etc

Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-09-05 Thread Ted Yu
bq. I did get tagged or I did comment on etc. What if nobody tags me on the PR and I don't comment on it ? Cheers On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 8:55 PM, Matthias J. Sax wrote: > >> If a person watches github PR, that person watches conversations on all > >> PRs, > > One can just "not watch" Kafka's G

Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-09-05 Thread Matthias J. Sax
>> If a person watches github PR, that person watches conversations on all >> PRs, One can just "not watch" Kafka's Github repo. I don't watch it either and thus I get emails for only those PRs I did get tagged or I did comment on etc. Would this not work for you? -Matthias On 9/5/17 7:31 PM,

Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-09-05 Thread Ted Yu
If a person watches github PR, that person watches conversations on all PRs, not just the one he / she intends to pay attention to. Quite often this leads to ton of emails in his / her inbox which is distracting. If the conversation is posted from PR to JIRA, watcher is per PR / JIRA. This is muc

Re: integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-09-05 Thread Matthias J. Sax
This integration was never set up for Kafka. I personally don't see any advantage in this, as it just duplicates everything and does not add value IMHO. The PRs are linked and one can go to the PR to read the discussion if interested. Or what do you think the value would be? -Matthias On 9/5/

integration between pull request and JIRA

2017-09-05 Thread Ted Yu
Hi, Currently the conversations on pull request are not posted back to JIRA. Is there technical hurdle preventing this from being done ? Other Apache projects, such as Flink, establish automatic post from pull request to JIRA. Cheers