Re: KIP Process Needs Improvement

2021-10-19 Thread Nikolay Izhikov
Hello, Knowles. I have some frustration with KIP process, also. Some features, that at glance requested by the community just can’t be done without explicit commiters approval. KIP-729 [1], KIP-686 [2], request the same feature, can be taken as a good example. Dear Kafka committers, what kind

Re: KIP Process Needs Improvement

2021-10-19 Thread John Roesler
Good morning Knowles, Thank you for sharing this feedback. I think your frustration is well founded. I think most/all of the active committers carry around a sense of guilt about KIPs that we haven’t been able to review. We do have a responsibility to hold auditable, public design discussions b