Hi, Xinyu,
Thanks for the KIP. A few high level comments.
JR1. One potential downside of using RF=1 is availability. Since there is
no active standby replica, on a failover, the new leader needs to recover
the log and rebuild/reload the state before it can serve writes. So, the
window of unavaila
Hi Colin,
Thank you for taking the time to read this KIP, and no worries, negative
feedback is a catalyst for improvement.
Sorry for the inappropriate description in the Motivation section; my
background influenced my writing, but I didn’t mean it. I will remove it.
Thanks for the reminder.
I co
Hi Xinyu Zhou,
Thanks for the KIP. It's good to see more people contributing to the community.
I think this is your first KIP, so please forgive me for giving some negative
feedback.
KIPs need to be written in a vendor-neutral manner, for the whole community. So
please do not do things like be
Hi Satish,
Thanks for your incisive comments!
For SD-1: I am now confident that we have a better chance of reaching a
consensus on the abstract layer. I will complete this part and address all
the questions from you and Luke. Once finished, I will ping you again.
For SD-2: In this KIP, a partiti
Thanks Xinyu for accepting our request to initiate a KIP on AutoMq's proposal.
SD-1: It is a good start towards building log storage layer
abstractions, including LogSegment and Log, for both local and shared
storage. However, more clarity is needed on how these abstractions are
defined. The class
Hi Luke,
Thank you for your review and insightful questions.
1. Regarding the future plan for this KIP, once we establish an abstract
log layer, we might implement a default version on object storage for
Kafka. For other types of shared storage, we'll decide based on community
needs.
2. In my vi
Hi Xinyu,
Thanks for the proposal!
I agree abstracting the log and logSegment layers can allow users to
implement any kinds of storage mediums.
Some high-level comments:
1. I expect to see the future plan of this KIP, but can't find it.
What do you expect to achieve the "shared storage" goal afte
