Re: [DISCUSS] KAFKA-17316 and KAFKA-17423

2024-09-03 Thread Colin McCabe
On Tue, Sep 3, 2024, at 01:46, Claude Warren, Jr wrote: > Colin, > > I can see that it makes sense to replace the StandardAuthorizer so that there > are not 2 implementations. However, I think the testing framework should > remain so that in future new improved implementations of > StandardAut

Re: [DISCUSS] KAFKA-17316 and KAFKA-17423

2024-09-03 Thread Claude Warren, Jr
Colin, I can see that it makes sense to replace the StandardAuthorizer so that there are not 2 implementations. However, I think the testing framework should remain so that in future new improved implementations of StandardAuthorizerData can be easily implemented and tested. I will put forward a

[DISCUSS] KAFKA-17316 and KAFKA-17423

2024-09-02 Thread Claude Warren, Jr
I have been working on implementing a Trie structure to store ACLs and improve the performance in the metadata/authorization code. The upshot of this was that I found it very difficult to determine if the implementation was correctly reimplementing the current implementation. My goal was to simpl