Hi Gabor,
It's a bit odd to get the following feedback from the Impala folks:
"I'd like to understand the motivation why this whole replication of code
happened between Iceberg and Hive."
when you know exactly why.
FYI, we've raised our concerns multiple times to the iceberg community, for
ex
> Let me know if the above doesn't make any sense, though!
To be honest, it doesn’t. The email feels accusatory, unfairly blaming
the Hive community for wrongdoing while portraying the Iceberg folks
as "worse" and insinuating misconduct on their part. This kind of tone
does nothing to foster conse
> Let me know if the above doesn't make any sense, though!
To be honest, it doesn’t. The email feels accusatory, unfairly blaming
the Hive community for wrongdoing while portraying the Iceberg folks
as "worse" and insinuating misconduct on their part. This kind of tone
does nothing to foster conse
I think that we should remove Hive 2 and Hive 3. We already agreed to
remove Hive 2, but Hive 3 is not compatible with the project anymore and is
already EOL and will not see a release to update it so that it can be
compatible. Anyone using the existing Hive 3 support should be able to
continue usi
Hey Cheng,
Thanks for the suggestion. The nightly snapshots are available:
https://repository.apache.org/content/groups/snapshots/org/apache/iceberg/iceberg-core/,
which might help when working on features that are not released yet (eg
Nanosecond timestamps). Besides that, we should run RCs agains
> That said, it would be helpful if they continue running
> tests against the latest stable Hive releases to ensure that any
> changes don’t unintentionally break something for Hive, which would be
> beyond our control.
> I believe we should continue maintaining a Hive Iceberg runtime test suite
Thanks Ayush&Stamatis for your input! I have created the ticket to remove the
auto-assign github-actions. Please check it. Thx.
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HIVE-28647
https://github.com/apache/hive/pull/5564
Thanks,
Butao Zhang
On 2024/11/25 08:44:28 Stamatis Zampetakis wrote:
> In
Hi All,
As I see there is a general opinion on not keeping the Hive code in the
Iceberg repo, but maintaining a set of tests that verifies the actual
Iceberg code against the latest Hive release. For me it would seem a bit
odd to maintain a test suite for verifying some code that is not maintained
