Re:Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread lisoda
Tips: As of now, one of the primary issues preventing users from upgrading to HIVE4 is the fact that HIVE4 is currently unable to interface with third-party systems such as Apache Ranger because of the many code changes made to HIVE4.It would be great if someone could submit patches to these pro

Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread lisoda
As a long time user of HIVE, I would like to join this discussion.And share some of my opinions. Due to the bad situation of HIVE3, users are divided into two broad types: 1. Still use HIVE1.X/2.X, and use Spark/Trino+HMS etc. to replace HIVEQL to some extent or completely replace HIVEQL. This pa

Re: Re:Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread Denys Kuzmenko
Hi @lisoda Thanks for bringing up the Ranger issue. It would be very helpful if you could share the JIRA with the issue details. Downstream we are using a version somewhat close to Hive-4.0 and it is fully integrated with Ranger. Another integration issue that I am familiar is HIVE-28211, that

Re:Re: Re:Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread lisoda
The main problem is that HIVE4 changed the variable names in HIVECONF, which caused some problems. At 2024-10-07 23:32:46, "Denys Kuzmenko" wrote: >Hi @lisoda > >Thanks for bringing up the Ranger issue. It would be very helpful if you could >share the JIRA with the issue details. Down

Re: Re: Re:Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread vihang karajgaonkar
Thanks everyone for freely expressing their opinions. Obviously it looks like some of the members here have strong opinions on what should be the future of Hive 3.x and since the consensus is towards EOLing it, I am not going to pursue this anymore. Let’s move forward with Hive 4 and make sure we

RE: Re: Re:Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread Sankar Hariappan
I honour community’s decision to EOL Hive 3.x which is fair based on consensus from community. I would like to acknowledge the efforts put in by contributors like Aman to backport 100+ patches from master to branch-3 and reviews from Vihang, Peter, Ayush which brought us close to 3.2 release. Th

Re: Re: Re:Re:Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: [DISCUSS] Hive 3.x release

2024-10-07 Thread Stamatis Zampetakis
Declaring Hive 3 as EOL is the right thing to do and as far as I see everyone is convinced about this thus I am not planning to change/retract my vote in the respective thread. Based on the current situation the 3.x EOL vote will pass. I was thinking that we could postpone the announcement for the