Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2025-01-06 Thread Sergio Chong Loo
Hi Alex and Yang, Apologies for the delayed reply… Yes I’d also love to share/exchange ideas. I’ll have a FLIP ready between this week and the next and we could continue the conversation there, does that sound good? Alex N. Indeed your solution sounds extremely similar! Let’s see what common

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-19 Thread Alex Nitavsky
Thanks Alexander for looking into email. - Should this reusable ProcessFunction filter out data or simply tag >them? For example, filtering data for green deployments would be > suitable >in the case of Async IO outputs. Consider a Flink job that mutates data in an external service us

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-17 Thread Alexander Fedulov
Hi Alex, - Should this reusable ProcessFunction filter out data or simply tag >them? For example, filtering data for green deployments would be > suitable >in the case of Async IO outputs. Could you clarify the idea a bit more, it is not quite clear what you mean. - Should we also

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-09 Thread Yang LI
Hello Sergio and Jose, Apologies for jumping into the conversation. I’m very interested in what you’ve learned about blue/green Flink deployments. I’m currently working on a project aimed at achieving no-downtime Flink deployments, so your insights would be highly valuable. Thank you, Yang

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-07 Thread Alex Nitavsky
>> Hi Sergio, >> >> +1 for starting a FLIP. >> >> I am wondering how non zero values for table.exec.source.idle-timeout >> and >> >> table.exec.state.ttl side effects, as they are based on clock time. It >> will >> >> be interest

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-06 Thread Alex Nitavsky
> table.exec.state.ttl side effects, as they are based on clock time. It > will > >> be interesting to identify these less stable scenarios and see what we > can > >> do with them. > >> > >> Kind regards, David. > >> > >> > >&

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-05 Thread Sergio Chong Loo
> Date: Wednesday, 4 December 2024 at 09:56 >> To: schong...@apple.com.invalid >> Cc: dev@flink.apache.org >> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink >> Hi Sergio, >> >> Out of the box blue/green deployments would be a great

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-05 Thread Alexander Fedulov
egards, David. > > > > > From: Maximilian Michels > Date: Wednesday, 4 December 2024 at 09:56 > To: schong...@apple.com.invalid > Cc: dev@flink.apache.org > Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink > Hi Sergio, > > Out of the box blue/green de

RE: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-04 Thread David Radley
, David. From: Maximilian Michels Date: Wednesday, 4 December 2024 at 09:56 To: schong...@apple.com.invalid Cc: dev@flink.apache.org Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink Hi Sergio, Out of the box blue/green deployments would be a great addition to Flink. +1 for

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-04 Thread Maximilian Michels
Hi Sergio, Out of the box blue/green deployments would be a great addition to Flink. +1 for starting a FLIP. That will allow us to better describe the architecture and flesh out the technical details. I reckon the handover between the two pipelines is going to be the most difficult part. Particul

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-12-03 Thread Sergio Chong Loo
Hi Danny… and community, At this point would it make sense for me to begin putting a FLIP together with more details and perhaps continue the conversation from there? Thanks, Sergio > On Nov 30, 2024, at 7:29 AM, Sergio Chong Loo wrote: > > Hey Danny > > Thanks for digging deeper into this t

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-11-30 Thread Sergio Chong Loo
Hey Danny Thanks for digging deeper into this topic! Indeed we’ve been giving a thought to most of these points but you’ve raised a couple of interesting ones, here are some ideas (inline): > On Nov 27, 2024, at 4:00 AM, Danny Cranmer wrote: > > Hello Sergio, > > Thankyou for starting this

Re: Blue/Green Deployments support for Flink

2024-11-27 Thread Danny Cranmer
Hello Sergio, Thankyou for starting this discussion, I have a few questions. > having 2 identical pipelines running side-by-side How do you ensure correctness between the 2 identical pipelines? For example, processing time semantics or late data can result in different outputs. Some Sources have