Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-21 Thread Alex Harui
On 11/21/14, 11:25 PM, "Justin Mclean" wrote: >Hi, > >Any objection to another RC not the NOTICE file and 3rd party examples >added? I reviewed the NOTICE and it looks ok so I think you are good to go. -Alex

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-21 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Any objection to another RC not the NOTICE file and 3rd party examples added? Thanks, Justin

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-21 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Fixed the NOTICE just waiting on the Flexilious images. Also changed the NOTICE title to accuratly reflect what teh notice refers to ie "Apache Flex Tour De Flex" rather than just "Apache Flex". Justin

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread Alex Harui
While researching an answer for Erik, I found the information I was looking for on Wikipedia attributions [1]. So listing the URL for the wikipedia content is the attribution that goes into NOTICE, so just fixing the URL in NOTICE should be sufficient. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:R

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread Alex Harui
On 11/19/14, 8:58 AM, "Justin Mclean" wrote: >I probably won't have time to do that until after ApacheCon and I'm back >in Australia. I'd suggest we release what we have now. Are you suggesting releasing RC1 with the NOTICE that points to freesound instead of wikipedia? I’ll be happy to change

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread OmPrakash Muppirala
On Wed, Nov 19, 2014 at 8:58 AM, Justin Mclean wrote: > Hi, > > > And from [3]: "Do not add anything to NOTICE which is not legally > > required." > > That correct but attribution IS legally required. Any license that > requires attribution needs to be added to NOTICE. I checked with a member > h

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > And from [3]: "Do not add anything to NOTICE which is not legally > required." That correct but attribution IS legally required. Any license that requires attribution needs to be added to NOTICE. I checked with a member here at ApacheCon and they confirmed that is the case. > I wish I’d

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread Erik de Bruin
> > Or how about this alternative? Since you aren’t linking to text from > wikipedia and instead are copying text from wikipedia, how about we copy > text from blogs.apache.org/flex? Then we can avoid this whole > LICENSE/NOTICE issue completely. > +1 This sounds like a supremely practical way

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread Alex Harui
On 11/19/14, 12:23 AM, "Justin Mclean" wrote: >>dActually, I looked and it is in LICENSE. Did we need this section in >> NOTICE at all? > >I believe so for the attribution. [1] says NOTICE may need to change. [2] >states that: >"Many of these licenses have specific attribution terms that need t

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-19 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, >> Sorry, looks like I missed that. I assume you meant to point to >> Wikipedia? Why is it in NOTICE and not in LICENSE? The content looks >> like it is CC-BY-SA which is Category A Which may still require changes to the NOTICE file and not just from information in other NOTICE files. >

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-18 Thread Alex Harui
On 11/18/14, 9:48 AM, "Alex Harui" wrote: >Sorry, looks like I missed that. I assume you meant to point to >Wikipedia? Why is it in NOTICE and not in LICENSE? The content looks >like it is CC-BY-SA which is Category A and the license and the wikipedia >page don’t seem to have a required noti

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-18 Thread Alex Harui
Sorry, looks like I missed that. I assume you meant to point to Wikipedia? Why is it in NOTICE and not in LICENSE? The content looks like it is CC-BY-SA which is Category A and the license and the wikipedia page don’t seem to have a required notices section. On 11/18/14, 5:57 AM, "Justin Mclean

Re: [DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-18 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Was just checking the RC and there an issue with the NOTICE file that will probably require a new RC (look at last URL) plus I'm still waiting on the Flexicious images. Thanks, Justin

[DISCUSS] TourDeFlex 1.2 RC1

2014-11-14 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Please place all discussion here and not in the VOTE thread. Thanks, Justin