Re: Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Matt Sicker
If Helm charts have similar licensing complexities as Docker images, then it probably makes sense to migrate charts to individual projects rather than making a larger chart repository here at Apache. If they don’t have similar licensing problems, then it could be aggregated like the Docker org, tho

Re: Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Dave Fisher
The ASF and the Apache Way is all about the community around an open source software project. If there is no community around this deprecated package then you will need to contact each Apache community that might be interested and ask them directly. If you have a group of developers who want to

Re: Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Ween Jiann
Hi Kamil, What's your take of having the helm chart in a single repo? It will lessen the load to maintain tests and distribution. On 2020/09/03 19:54:17, Kamil Breguła wrote: > Hello, > > In the case of Airflow, we have developed our own chart and want to develop > and release it soon. For now

Re: Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Ween Jiann
Hi Dave, Just to clarify, my suggestion is to move only charts related to ASF projects to the apache git repo. These charts have been deprecated as part of the repo deprecation, they have no choice but to move somewhere or be archived. If this gains some traction, I'll create an issue and conta

Re: Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Dave Fisher
Hi - Does the Helm Chart community wish to explore becoming an Apache Project Community? Regards, Dave Sent from my iPhone > On Sep 3, 2020, at 12:33 PM, Ween Jiann wrote: > > Hi all, > > The helm team has deprecated the charts repository and will be archiving it > in Nov. Here’s the link

Re: Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Kamil Breguła
Hello, In the case of Airflow, we have developed our own chart and want to develop and release it soon. For now, there is little chance that our community will be interested in developing two independent charts. https://github.com/apache/airflow/issues/10523 That would be the 3rd method of deploy

Migration and consolidation helm charts for ASF projects from helm/charts to apache/charts git

2020-09-03 Thread Ween Jiann
Hi all, The helm team has deprecated the charts repository and will be archiving it in Nov. Here’s the link to the notice https://github.com/helm/charts/blob/master/README.md#deprecation-timeline It looks like that are quite a few charts for ASF projects such as Airflow, Hadoop, Spark, Solr