Email address added to postgresql.org organisation

2024-12-09 Thread webmaster
Hello! You are receiving this email because this address was added to the organisation Apache Cloudberry on www.postgresql.org. If this is not correct, please ignore this email and the record of the address will be automatically deleted. If this is correct, please click the below link to confirm

Re: Email address added to postgresql.org organisation

2024-12-09 Thread Dianjin Wang
Hi everyone, I have registered the org `Apache Cloudberry` on the PostgreSQL website. You can find us here: https://www.postgresql.org/account/orglist/. In the future, we can share Cloudberry's milestone news, such as releases, through the PostgreSQL news channel. Later, I will try to submit our

Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Cloudberry CI Implementation Update

2024-12-09 Thread Dianjin Wang
Run the test image successfully on my Macbook. Approved. Thanks! Best, Dianjin Wang On Mon, Dec 9, 2024 at 10:52 PM Dianjin Wang wrote: > Thanks so much, Ed! I really appreciate it. I'll take a look later. > If anyone else is available to help with the technical review, that would > be better,

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Greg Spiegelberg
I like the Clickhouse year version number thought but feel it doesn't communicate enough and could potentially mean a 2024 major release is where Cloudberry is at in 2025 which is not a message worth communicating. Along the year number line of thought, consider PostgreSQL does major releases annu

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Antonio Petrole
Lots of great thoughts in this thread. Just want to share the sentiment as someone who did professional services for Greenplum for almost a decade that something like pg_upgrade would be really *really *great to have to perform whatever conversions need to happen for major upgrades with the user da

Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Cloudberry CI Implementation Update

2024-12-09 Thread Dianjin Wang
Thanks so much, Ed! I really appreciate it. I'll take a look later. If anyone else is available to help with the technical review, that would be better, thanks in advance. On Monday, December 9, 2024, Ed Espino wrote: > Dianjin, > > I have a PR (https://github.com/apache/cloudberry-devops-releas

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Roman Shaposhnik
On Mon, Dec 9, 2024 at 3:27 AM Ed Espino wrote: > > Hi Andrey, > > Thanks for bringing up the ClickHouse versioning model - it's a fascinating > alternative to consider. I particularly like how the year-based scheme > instantly communicates version currency to users and the tiered > functionality

Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Cloudberry CI Implementation Update

2024-12-09 Thread Ed Espino
Dianjin, I have a PR (https://github.com/apache/cloudberry-devops-release/pull/8) that addresses this issue. If you could review and possibly approve, we will have arm64 containers for Rocky 8 & 9. -=e On Sun, Dec 8, 2024 at 7:07 PM Dianjin Wang wrote: > Hi Ed, > > I encountered an issue while

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Ed Espino
Hi Andrey, Thanks for bringing up the ClickHouse versioning model - it's a fascinating alternative to consider. I particularly like how the year-based scheme instantly communicates version currency to users and the tiered functionality approach. After considering both approaches, I still lean tow

Re: [D] Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry [cloudberry]

2024-12-09 Thread via GitHub
GitHub user edespino added a comment to the discussion: Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry @yjhjstz As far as the Apache Cloudberry project is concerned, if they are needed, these resources should be reworked to use the DockerHub Apache Cl

Re: [D] Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry [cloudberry]

2024-12-09 Thread via GitHub
GitHub user yjhjstz added a comment to the discussion: Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry https://github.com/apache/cloudberry/blob/main/deploy/docker/Dockerfile docker.artifactory.hashdata.xyz/docker/cbdb:devel-devtoolset-10-cbdb-docker-ub

Re: [D] Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry [cloudberry]

2024-12-09 Thread via GitHub
GitHub user edespino added a comment to the discussion: Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry @yjhjstz I am not sure what you mean by _"maybe we need a pipeline to sync docker sandbox image ?"_ GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/cloudber

Re: [Discussion] Proposal for Cloudberry Roadmap

2024-12-09 Thread Dianjin Wang
Hi everyone, Happy Monday! Last week, we received a lot of valuable feedback from the community—thank you for sharing your insights! I truly appreciate the strength of our community. This week, we will continue the discussion. Please feel free to share more thoughts via the mailing list or commen

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Max Yang
Hi Ed, Agree that we have the first version 2.0 first, which can help us go through the entire process and run the release pipeline. Generally speaking, the time for the first release will be longer than later. Thank you for volunteering as the release manager. Your many experiences will definite

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Max Yang
Hi Andrey, Good to see you!!! Yes, we need to add some checks in codes to let the program automatically discover incompatible issues. As for the issue of functional classification, it can be added with corresponding tags during code review, and the document can be associated with this information

Re: [D] Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry [cloudberry]

2024-12-09 Thread via GitHub
GitHub user tuhaihe added a comment to the discussion: Sync up behavior on how partition maintenance works between Greenplum 6/7 and Cloudberry I'm uncertain about this, but I would like to involve @edespino. GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/cloudberry/discussions/691#discussioncomment-

Re: When to release Cloudberry 2.0

2024-12-09 Thread Andrey M. Borodin
> On 9 Dec 2024, at 11:26, Max Yang wrote: > > Welcome to discuss Hi! Let’s consider also Clickhouse versioning. Clickhouse version is “year.release.patch”. Also they add tags “stable” or “lts” to some releases. The basic idea is that you have continuous development process not tied to sp