Re: Paxos repairs in CEP-14

2021-12-04 Thread bened...@apache.org
> As the repair is only guaranteed for a majority of replicas, I assume I can discover somewhere which replicas are up to date like this? I’m not quite sure what you mean. Do you mean which nodes have participated in a paxos repair? This information isn’t maintained, but anyway would not imply t

Re: [DISCUSS] Disabling MIME-part filtering on this mailing list

2021-12-04 Thread bened...@apache.org
I think you were correct to start a DISCUSS thread, Bowen. You should not start a vote until you have first established if there is consensus. Also, I agree with the proposal. From: Bowen Song Date: Saturday, 4 December 2021 at 23:12 To: dev@cassandra.apache.org Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Disablin

Re: [DISCUSS] Disabling MIME-part filtering on this mailing list

2021-12-04 Thread Bowen Song
Hmm.. It's too late to change that. I opened it as "DISCUSS" because I was not sure if the information in it is enough for people to vote on it. There's clearly a lot more can be asked or discussed. For example the change will also stop the "To unsubscribe, ..." footer being appended to some em

Paxos repairs in CEP-14

2021-12-04 Thread Henrik Ingo
Could someone elaborate on this section *Paxos Repair* We will introduce a new repair mechanism, that can be run with or without regular repair. This mechanism will: - Track, per-replica, transactions that have been witnessed as initiated but have not been seen to complete - For a

RE: [DISCUSS] Disabling MIME-part filtering on this mailing list

2021-12-04 Thread Mick Semb Wever
> What's your opinion on this? Do you support or oppose disabling the > MIME-part filtering on the Cassandra-dev mailing list? +1 (nit: am thinking the thread should have had a [VOTE] prefix, since you are calling out for consensus)

Re: [DISCUSS] Disabling MIME-part filtering on this mailing list

2021-12-04 Thread J. D. Jordan
+1 (nb) from me. I have always wondered why the signatures were broken. That JIRA thread is very enlightening on how those email features work :). > On Dec 4, 2021, at 11:18 AM, C. Scott Andreas wrote: > > +1, this would be great to have fixed. Thanks for talking with Infra about > this, Bow

Re: [DISCUSS] Disabling MIME-part filtering on this mailing list

2021-12-04 Thread C. Scott Andreas
+1, this would be great to have fixed. Thanks for talking with Infra about this, Bowen. > On Dec 4, 2021, at 9:16 AM, Bowen Song wrote: > > Hello, > > > Currently this mailing list has MIME-part filtering turned on, which will > results in "From:" address munging (appending ".INVALID" to th

[DISCUSS] Disabling MIME-part filtering on this mailing list

2021-12-04 Thread Bowen Song
Hello, Currently this mailing list has MIME-part filtering turned on, which will results in "From:" address munging (appending ".INVALID" to the sender's email address) for domains enforcing strict DMARC rules, such as apple.com, zoho.com and all Yahoo.** domains. This behaviour may cause so

Re: [DISCUSS] Releasable trunk and quality

2021-12-04 Thread Joshua McKenzie
After some offline collab, here's where this thread has landed on a proposal to change our processes to incrementally improve our processes and hopefully stabilize the state of CI longer term: Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tJ-0K7d6PIStSbNFOfynXsD9RRDaMgqCu96U4O-RT84/edit#bookmark=id.16