Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread Joshua McKenzie
One thing probably worth thinking about: we're a mostly irascible lot to begin with and there's a global pandemic and Human Race Lockdown. I don't know about the rest of you but I'm starting from a pretty not-chill place these days; trying to be mindful of that. So for this: if we require a protoc

Re: Kubernetes operator unification

2020-04-02 Thread Stefan Miklosovic
Hi, first of all I think that we should not reinvent the wheel here. I think that I am not far from the truth when I say that Orange's operator is the most mature one when it comes to features and the most battle-tested. I have not checked how it is done in details internally yet but I am satisfie

Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread sankalp kohli
Whether a feature is fully done and whether it validates or invalidate testing is not the point here. The point is that it is a feature and violates feature freeze. If someone brings in a feature which is almost done and does not invalidate testing then will we merge all of them to 4.0? Lot of feat

Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread Jon Haddad
Chris's original patch used a virtual table which didn't even require a protocol change. To me, the difference between having a CQL describe vs a virtual table is unimportant, since it's only drivers that need to care about it. I'm completely fine with the simpler implementation of a virtual tabl

Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread Nate McCall
So summarizing the salient points here: - client authors have worked around this mostly, but this would avoid some duplication of effort for new features - this issues was tagged last year as being pertinent to 4.0 in several threads about what was in scope - there is some development efforts requi

Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread Aleksey Yeshchenko
Yeah, I feel like it’s a bad example to use to highlight 4.0 scope creep (which is less of a thing than some fear). The work there is already done, and it’s extremely unintrusive. There is no reason whatsoever to block 4.0 on it, but no reason not to commit - now, in a beta, in the first RC, or

Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread Benedict Elliott Smith
Sorry if this is a repeat message; I messed up my mail client settings (I don't see it today, but it might just be stuck in an unmonitored moderator queue): I think it is unfair to label this scope creep; it would have to be newly considered for 4.0 for it to fall under that umbrella, surely? I

Re: Kubernetes operator unification

2020-04-02 Thread franck.dehay
Hi all, We at Orange would love to be included in these talks about a unique Kubernetes operator for Cassandra. It comes a bit late for us as we have spent a couple of years on ours and are close to running it in production but moving to a community supported one will be better for everybod

Re: server side describe

2020-04-02 Thread Benjamin Lerer
+1 for shipping it after 4.0 On Thu, Apr 2, 2020 at 12:39 AM Jon Haddad wrote: > Most of the work to provide this feature is already done. We need to > generate server side CQL for snapshots already. All we need to do is > expose it via either a "DESCRIBE" CQL command, or I'm equally happy t