Re: Code style and root package

2022-10-21 Thread Bertil Chapuis
>> Changing package names is probably harmless. But file headers and >> copyright notices should not be changed until after IP transfer >> (repository migration). The license header was changed before this discussion (19 days ago). The LICENSE.header file contained an outdated copyright notice (

Re: Code style and root package

2022-10-21 Thread Calvin Kirs
On Fri, Oct 21, 2022 at 3:19 AM Bertil Chapuis wrote: > > > >> Changing package names is probably harmless. But file headers and > >> copyright notices should not be changed until after IP transfer > >> (repository migration). > > The license header was changed before this discussion (19 days ago)

Re: Code style and root package

2022-10-21 Thread Bertil Chapuis
>> In terms of license, all the LGPL dependencies have been replaced last >> summer. My main concern is related to the osmpbf data format. The protobuf >> descriptor used by this format is released under the terms of the GNU Lesser >> General Public License. In my understanding this file should

Re: Code style and root package

2022-10-21 Thread Martin Desruisseaux
Le 21/10/2022 à 13:19, Bertil Chapuis a écrit : (…snip…) You are right, apparently the output of a generator inherits the license of the template. (…snip…) George and Martin, do you have experience with this kind of issues and on how to address it? In my understanding of [1], the GPL-derived w

Re: Code style and root package

2022-10-21 Thread Bertil Chapuis
After spending some time > On 21 Oct 2022, at 16:37, Martin Desruisseaux > wrote: > > Le 21/10/2022 à 13:19, Bertil Chapuis a écrit : >> (…snip…) You are right, apparently the output of a generator inherits the >> license of the template. (…snip…) George and Martin, do you have experience >>

Re: Code style and root package

2022-10-21 Thread Julian Hyde
Regarding the GPL/LGPL dependencies. It is true that an ASF top-level project cannot make releases with those dependencies. But these issues can be solved during incubation. Incubating projects have some leeway while making their first releases. I suggest that you do not try to solve the GPL/LGP