Re: [DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-22 Thread Sebastien Goasguen
On Apr 22, 2014, at 3:46 PM, Henry Saputra wrote: > If you look at many of existing ASF projects, including the big ones, > not many of them have "shepherds". > > When someone has question then sending email to dev@ list is the way > to go and the community should be able to help. > I agree w

Re: [DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-22 Thread Henry Saputra
If you look at many of existing ASF projects, including the big ones, not many of them have "shepherds". When someone has question then sending email to dev@ list is the way to go and the community should be able to help. We could use prefix in subject to help define topics or certain discussions

Re: [DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-22 Thread Bill Farner
I disagree that shepherding is unneeded. Just having a de-facto tier one support contact is huge to help acquaint a new developer. Perhaps our definitions of shepherd differs, i'm thinking of it amounting to "when you have questions, [committer name] is here to help you". -=Bill On Tue, Apr 22

Re: [DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-22 Thread Henry Saputra
I think for small community like Aurora we do not need shepherding for contributors. We could do it via JIRA and review boards as Sebastien mentioned. If a contributor is interested in certain feature then one of the PPMCs could just engage and help driving through solution. Once contributions co

Re: [DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-22 Thread Sebastien Goasguen
> On 22 Apr 2014, at 20:04, Bill Farner wrote: > > Some things not yet addressed (some have obvious solutions, but still > warrant explicit discussion): > > - What is expected of a shepherd? > > - How does a newcomer learn that we have a shepherd program? > > - How is a shepherd assigned Do

Re: [DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-22 Thread Bill Farner
Some things not yet addressed (some have obvious solutions, but still warrant explicit discussion): - What is expected of a shepherd? - How does a newcomer learn that we have a shepherd program? - How is a shepherd assigned? -=Bill On Mon, Apr 21, 2014 at 5:27 PM, Jake Farrell wrote: > As

[DISCUSS] shepherding contributors

2014-04-21 Thread Jake Farrell
As part of our first IRC meeting one of the topics that came up was shepherding contributors that have shown interest and how we can help and encourage them into committer roles and grow the community. Opening this discussion thread so we can flush out any ideas not brought up during the meeting