Re: [FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-07-25 Thread David Li
Got it. It seems there's potential benefits to have this work together with Spark Connect (at least, there's two very similar wire protocols going on that could possibly be consolidated). Have you shown this to the Spark community as well? You caught me in the middle of things, the PR to add th

Re: [FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-07-25 Thread Tornike Gurgenidze
1) David, thanks for mentioning that. tbh, this is the first time I'm reading about it. If we are talking only about SparkFlightSql, It does seem similar in the sense that both use Arrow for streaming data back to the client. The difference is the Spark Connect client still has a dependency on Spar

Re: [FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-07-25 Thread David Li
So this is now both a Flight SQL producer and consumer for Spark? That is very cool. A couple things I was wondering about: - How do you think this compares to the Spark Connect proposal? [1] - Have you considered ADBC [2] instead of Flight SQL for the DataSourceV2 implementation? While still u

Re: [FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-07-23 Thread Gavin Ray
This sounds pretty darn nifty! I don't have much of value to offer, but the idea sounds like a great one to me =) On Sat, Jul 23, 2022 at 5:18 PM Tornike Gurgenidze wrote: > David, thank you for the reply. > > I recently managed to find the time to get back to the repo. I thought I > would post

Re: [FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-07-23 Thread Tornike Gurgenidze
David, thank you for the reply. I recently managed to find the time to get back to the repo. I thought I would post the status update for anyone interested. The project started out as just FlightSql implementation, but I ended up splitting it into smaller components: 1. SparkFlightManager - a lo

Re: [FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-05-28 Thread David Li
Hi Tornike, I'll have to take a closer look later when I can get back in front of a real computer but I just want to say that this is super awesome, and thank you for sharing! I think we've kicked around the idea of "contrib" projects in the past. Maybe this can be the impetus to take up that

[FlightSql] Spark Flight SQL

2022-05-28 Thread Tornike Gurgenidze
Hi, I'm not sure this is the right place to be posting this, so I apologize in advance. Recently I started a PoC for Arrow Flight SQL Server with Spark backend ( https://github.com/tokoko/SparkFlightSql). The main goal is to create a SparkThriftServer alternative that will benefit from FlightSql